Which asscher do you prefer?

[flknight]

I know it''s so hard to tell from these photos but which asscher do you prefer?

On the left:
GIA Report
Square Emerald
6.96 x 6.88 x 4.79 mm
2.01
F
VS2
Polish - Ex
Symmetry - VG
Flourescence - None
Table - 62%
Depth - 69.6%

On the right (this is the same one I posted the other day):
GIA Report
Square Emerald
6.95 x 6.94 x 4.78 mm
2.01
F
VS2
Polish - Ex
Symmetry - G
Flourescence - None
Table - 60%
Depth - 68.9%

 

[flknight]

Here is another...

 

[purrfectpear]

With tilt and what have you, it''s hard to be fair. Based strictly on the photos, I like the one on the left.

 

[strmrdr]

one on the left looks better.
Wish you had some better pictures.

 

[chrono]

It''s so hard to tell; the pictures are small and it is hard to make out the details.

 

[Ice Princess Cristy]

I agree with the others, it''s so hard to tell.... the one on the left looks "prettier" and has more sparkle and colors.... but does the one on the right look a little bigger to anyone else? I guess if it does, then it would depend if you wanted one that showed a little bigger or showed a little more brillance....

 

[Kaleigh]

Can you ask for more pics? I like the one on the left, but hard to say as the pic isn''t very good...

 

[kcoursolle]

I can''t make a judgement from the pictures, but the one on the right looks bigger to me. Both look very pretty.

 

[flknight]

Thank you all for the feedback! I have a few more pics but I''m not going to bother to post them because none of them are that great. I think I''m leaning toward the one on the left as well. The table is a little big but I actually like that look. I didn''t notice that the one on the left looked smaller but after IPK pointed it out, I have to agree so that might influence the decision although I think I really do prefer the left stone, even if it faces up a bit smaller.

 

[dogmama]

It''s hard to tell. BUT I have to say the one on the left looks sparklier. It caught my eye first. It may face up smaller but it will depend on the setting you choose on how to maximize it.

 

[Ellen]

To me eye, as far as the right one looking bigger, I think it looks taller and more narrow, whereas the other looks slightly shorter and wider. I could see where at a glance it could look bigger.

I like the one on the left based on these pics.

 

[strmrdr]

While the opinions are valid that one looks bigger than the other and it does. BUT...
That lighting is one of the absolute worst for judging asschers.
The most that can be taken from them is the one on the left has slightly more even center and slightly better windmills.
Neither diamond will ever look exactly like that mounted in a ring and on someones finger.

The pictures arent good enough too make a kicken determinination.
Make sure the place has a good return policy if not seeing them in person before purchase if you buy one of them.