which 2 stones - based on specs should I choose

[D2B]

Hi

well I have narrowed it down to 2 stones for my three stone upgrade. My side stones are G/H therefore the colour of the stone is not a factor as I could easily go either way (G or H), nor is the size really, as I a bit worried the 1.12 is too big ( I know - weird!!!)

Anyway, so based on just the cut and performance of the stones, not colour or size I would love your input which is better - both perform excellent on the cut advisor

Stone 1 .92c
colour G SI1 AGS 0
Dim 6.26
Depth: 3.84 61.3%
Pav depth: 42.9
Pav angle: 40.7
Crown height 15.1%
Crown angle 34.8
Table size 56.7%
Cutlet 0.6
Girdle min 1.6
Girdle max 2.1
Star upper Ratio 53:47

Stone 2
1.12c H colour, SI1
AGS 0

Diameter 6.66
total depth 61.6% 4.10mm
Pav depth 43.0%
Pav angle 40.8
Crown height 14.9
crown angle 34.7
Table size 56.9
Culet 0.4
girdle min 1.8
Girdle maz 2.3
Star/Upper ratio 54:46

I will try and attache the Idealscopes and ASET pictures, I dont have any ASET for the 1.12 yet.

I am not feeling well today, so spending my time on Pricescope whilst in bed seems like a good way to go

I would really appreciate some more input, as the more feedback the better - so which looks best for sparkle and performance?

thanks again
db

Stone 1
.92

 

[D2B]

Stone 1
.92 next picture

 

[Ellen]

Well on paper they both have lots of potential, and the pics of the first one confirms it''s a winner.

 

[D2B]

Stone 2

1.12

Need to chase up the ASET, but all feedback is really welcome, as to which stone do you think would perform better, as I said the colour or size are not really an issue for me

thanks heaps

 

[Ellen]

No real need for the ASET, IS is preferred on rounds anyway. They will both be top performers. Flip a coin!

 

[D2B]

Thanks Ellen

Reallly appreciate your feedback and time

cheers
Db

 

[Lorelei]

Both gorgeous!!

 

[stone-cold11]

Both look good to me too.

 

[Ellen]

Date: 8/12/2009 12:36:33 AM
Author: D2B
Thanks Ellen

Reallly appreciate your feedback and time

cheers
Db

You''re welcome! Have you decided yet?