What would you choose?

[singer]

#1 or #3...but I think I prefer #3!

 

[Elegant]

I like #2...is it a very tall setting though?

 

[MichelleCarmen]

I''d for sure pick #1. It''s classic and will remain so throughout your life AND if you do need a bit of variety, you can always add a few different sorts of wedding bands to mix and match.

Congrats on your 20th!

 

[Monnyjay]

l absolutely love Diamondseekers set, timeless/classic/elegant like Audrey Hepburn, so my choice is 1. Congratulations also on 20 years, I had mine last November

 

[Adah]

I am partial to antique-look settings so I''m voting for number 2.

But all 3 are fabulous choices!

 

[gwendolyn]

Numero uno in a heartbeat! I''m a size 9 girl as well who loves her jeans as well, and diamondseeker''s set is one of my all-time favourites. That Leon setting is just GORGEOUS in its elegance. My top choice by far! Can''t wait to hear what you choose!

 

[Ellen]

Well "I" would go for ds''s, but I''m a total minimalist. If you really love all three of these, for you I''d probably say 2. It''s a lovely setting, and it will give you the size you are wanting, and may crave if you don''t get it. As for it possibly being trendy, I say meh, buy what you love, and wear it proudly!

 

[loveloveloveit]

such hard decisions! at first I thought definitely no 1, but on re-reading your post I think no 2 is quite unique and you would get a bit more bling for your buck ... so no 2 for me. They''re all beautiful though, you just can''t go wrong

 

[kimmyintexas]

You ladies are all so awesome!! This is really helping me...thank you!

 

[emeraldlover1]

That is a tough one because they are soooo different. I''m a true step cut lover so for me the choice is obvious. I honestly think that #2 might be a good choice for you because it incorporates all of the elements of the other two rings.

 

[Ellen]

Date: 5/23/2009 9:44:56 AM
Author: kimmyintexas
You ladies are all so awesome!! This is really helping me...thank you!

Good! Now just don''t leave us hanging, or we''ll have to hunt you down to find out what you ended up with.

 

[canuk-gal]

HI:

First 20 years I had a solitare like DS, then got a three stone ring for my anniversary. I am seriously looking for another round (RB) which will set into another solitare setting. Go I guess #1 is my choice!

cheers--Sharon

 

[Burk]

Another vote for number 1. Number 3 is very close though. Good luck!

 

[ilovethiswebsite]

I would definitely go with number 1 or 2. I love round brilliants and they sparkle like no other. #1 is very classic and timeless and you probably would never get sick of it (even in 40 years from now). But number 2 is a conversation piece, extremely unique and beautiful. You would 100% get compliments ALL the time... But you *may* get sick of it sometime down the road like 20 plus years from now because of how ornate it is. It really depends on your personality - if you are a unique person and enjoy being different - go with #2. If your style is more timeless and classic, go with number 1!!!

 

[snow483]

I tend to be drawn towards more classic settings but I love love love #2! #1 would be my second choice. #3 is beautiful, but I like the discoball sparkle of round diamonds.

 

[lyra]

I love #2, but then I''m willing to take chances. I think with a size 9 finger, it would be enough bling and coverage for you. Otherwise I''d go for size on #1 if you can. I have a size 7 finger and personally don''t feel like 2 cts is big enough for a solitaire, I''d love to go 2.5 to 3.0, but it will never happen.

 

[diamondringlover]

#1, I would go for large solitare with a nice band

 

[mrssalvo]

totally #1 all the way. I actually went with a pave halo ring and it was too much for me. I''m going back to a solitaire and the great thing is you can get a bunch of different wedding bands to mix it up if you want...although DS''s legacy with the leon is just perfection!!!

 

[brightlight]

I really like #2, but there''s something about a solitaire that''s so beautiful.

 

[galligirl]

Either 1 or 2. I don''t like Emerald, they don''t sparkle. I''m not crazy about bagettes, but 2 is very pretty and makes me forget that. I really do like 1.