WF vs JA Men''s Comfort Fit Band?

[han001]

Does anyone know whether Whiteflash or James Allen offer a better stock Men''s Comfort Fit Band in terms of style, quality, weight etc?

I know both WF and JA have made many PSers very happy, but there is almost a $400 difference in price for their respective platinum 5MM Men''s Comfort Fit bands (James Allen more expensive). Is there really is a big difference between the two?

I''m looking for an alternative to Tiffany''s 4.5mm Lucida band.

Any insight is appreciated! Thanks!

http://www.whiteflash.com/golden-wardrobe/gold_details.aspx?ItemCode=STCF4MMPL&CategID=10
http://www.jamesallen.com/wedding-rings/mens-wedding-bands/5mm-mens-platinum-wedding-band.html

 

[Dreamer_D]

Both are overpriced.

www.eweddingbands.com is the most economical place to order plain plat bands that I have seen. The quality is awesome. A large number of PSers have used them and been very happy. I have bought from them. They will also customize.

http://www.e-weddingbands.com/store/platcf5linfo.html

ETA Here is a heavier band: http://www.e-weddingbands.com/store/platcf5info.html

 

[han001]

Thanks Dreamer, I''ll check it out!

While price is important, I''m most concerned with style, workmanship and quality. Tiffany''s pieces are obviously beautiful, and I know that WF can match it.

Can you say the same thing of e-weddingbands?

Thanks!

 

[Dreamer_D]

Date: 3/7/2010 1:17:19 AM
Author: han001
Thanks Dreamer, I''ll check it out!

While price is important, I''m most concerned with style, workmanship and quality. Tiffany''s pieces are obviously beautiful, and I know that WF can match it.

Can you say the same thing of e-weddingbands?

Thanks!

Honestly, I am willing to bet you $100 bucks that all of these rings come from the same casting company. I really doubt that they are casting them in house, not for an item like this. A comfort fit half round band is pretty much the same wherever it is from. Besides, if you are not happy you can return it without any hassel. But I would not spend double for such a simple item.

I have ordered wbs from both WF and eweddingbands and they are identical except that one is 2mm and one is 3mm. Its a metal ring, KWIM? It isn''t pave or anything

You can look up on their websites to see the exact metal compostion if that matters to you, perhaps that is a tipping point.

Also try a search to find many consumer testimonials about eweddingbands.com

 

[Bosie]

Agree with Dreamer 100%. I bought my wedding band from eweddingbands.com, quality is excellent, and it looks great, and oh, one more thing, saved money. Best of luck.
(4mm comfort fit, plat)

ps. I considered the heavier band, glad I did not go with it. I wear my ring 24/7, never take it off.

 

[small_paws]

I''m so glad I found this thread, I was actually looking at sites for my hubby''s band and took a moment from looking at the above named site to look in this thread. So glad that others have been happy b/c this is who we''ve been looking at going through.