Viewing analysis reports to determine the best diamond?

[HopeSheSaysYes]

Hey there PriceScopers!

I'm very new to the forum, so I hope I could get some help with my dilemma.

I've been trying to shop for a diamond, and currently I have (sort of) narrowed it down to two diamonds. http://i.imgur.com/7gpQ0dq.jpg

Would anyone be able to help me out in terms of determining which one of the two are better in terms of Clarity, Cut, Color (I am not even sure if you can determine that by the analysis), maybe even which one you would choose?

You're advice is appreciated!

 

[OoohShiny]

I can't see imgur links at work as are blocked.

Please can you post the GIA or AGS numbers for the stones?

Have you put the measurements through the Holloway Cut Advisor tool on this website?

 

[tyty333]

They both look like nice stones and don't show any leakage in the ideal scope.

Can you give the gia/ags numbers so we
Double check everything.

 

[John P]

http://i.imgur.com/7gpQ0dq.jpg

Love the screen name.

Be aware that these are not actual images. They were created by plugging the mm dimensions and averaged (possibly rounded) proportions into software. That produced "perfect" wire frame outlines, but the actual diamond could look much different in real viewing in ASET-IS and esp H&A viewers, depending on its cut-consistency, actual numbers and variations-from average.

It's nice that the seller is working to give you something, but these do not represent the actual diamond. I'd ask for actual photos, or have them run a full 3D .SRN scan in this software. Plugging in averages is not conclusive.