Video comparison: Which of these would you pick and why?

[itsaSecret]

I decided to start another post so I wouldn''t clutter up the other one.

Without any specific numbers or pricing information, which of these four stones is most appealing to you and why? I am having a hard time finding any major differences! They are all amazing.

http://vimeo.com/2290282

 

[itsaSecret]

Sniff Sniff. I smell lurkers! A couple dozen views and no comments yet? I just want a simple opinion.


Thanks in advance.

 

[ImpatientOne]

I agree - they are all gorgeous, but I''d probably go with #4 followed by #1 and this is just based on the visuals

 

[Ellen]

Really splitting hairs here, as they are all great! I would pick #1 if you made me, because it looks like it might be just a bit brighter than the others in diffused lighting, and certainly performed well in spot lighting.

 

[kelbelle134]

Love that video--totally cool! I am no where near an expert, but love the 4th- for the balance of the size and the way it sparkles, then the 1st which in my opinion is best fire/brilliance performing stone. ETA: they are all gorgeous and I don't think you can go wrong with any of them!!

 

[coatimundi_org]

Date: 11/19/2008 7:14:54 PM
Author: Ellen
Really splitting hairs here, as they are all great! I would pick #1 if you made me, because it looks like it might be just a bit brighter than the others in diffused lighting, and certainly performed well in spot lighting.

Ditto--sheesh! They all look great! I do like the look of the first from the slightly larger pavillion angle, but that''s being inordinately picky.

 

[rainydaze]

i like the first - i picked a 41 degree pavillion angle diamond in another video GOG put out specifically comparing the very picky diffences created by differing pav angles. i like how that angle gives "color/fire" to the arrows.

my second favorite is the fourth.

good luck deciding, they are all beauts!

 

[itsaSecret]

Thanks. I agree with everyone. My personal preference is #4 because of the size and cost ratio. The funny thing is that those two are the least expensive out of the bunch. I think we may have ourselves a winner folks!