shape
carat
color
clarity

Valuation under purchase price for Whiteflash ACA

tkyoung1

Rough_Rock
Joined
Nov 10, 2014
Messages
4
Hi,

Recently bought a Whiteflash ACA round brilliant with setting.
The ring looks stunning.

We recently got around to having it valued for insurance purposes. We wanted a reputable store, so chose a jeweller in Melbourne whose founder is at the forefront of diamond cut.

We were a bit shocked when the valuation came 15% under what we paid for it.

We're located in Australia, so to purchase a direct replacement from whiteflash you have to account for the exchange rate plus 10% sales tax. The figure given is actually fairly close to the purchase price in Australian Dollars without taking into account the 10% sales tax and customs fees.

From the reading I've done it seems the overwhelming majority of jewellers tend to grossly overvalue.

Now I'm not after a high valuation for ego purposes and high premiums, but am worried the ring is a little underinsured. At a minimum I'd like to insure it at it's true replacement value.

Does anyone have any thoughts on this? We're thinking of asking the jeweller how they came to their valuation. Can you challenge a valuation? Has anyone else done this? Would you just take it to another jeweller?
 
Is there an independent appraiser you could take it to in Melbourne? That way, you could get an independent appraisal rather than a jeweler which may have their own agenda?

The value of the Aussie dollar against the US dollar has plummeted recently which does make the purchase of diamonds overseas a little less attractive at the moment, I think.
 
BlingObsession|1421054421|3815157 said:
Is there an independent appraiser you could take it to in Melbourne? That way, you could get an independent appraisal rather than a jeweler which may have their own agenda?

The value of the Aussie dollar against the US dollar has plummeted recently which does make the purchase of diamonds overseas a little less attractive at the moment, I think.

Cheers,

Didn't think of an independent appraiser - if anyone has any suggestions that would be great. It's weird that diamonds on this particular jeweller's website 0.1c bigger, 1 grade less clarity and colour, not sure about cut (but can't get any better than ags0), is almost double in price.

Yep we got in when the AUD was 0.87, but I would have thought that would increase our valuation slightly.
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top