Thoughts on these two diamonds?

[jaycruz]

Both diamonds are over 1.2CT with I color.
First one is a VVS1 with faint fluorescence.
Second one is a VS1 with medium blue and .07CT heavier with face up size being 0.05mm larger.
Pricing is basically the same, within $100 of each other.




Depth - 61.2%
Table - 57%
Crown - 34
Pavilion - 40.6
Girdle - Med-Slightly Thick - 4.0%






Depth - 62.8%
Table - 56%
Crown - 34.5
Pavilion - 41
Girdle - Slightly Thick - 4.0%

 

[jaycruz]

Another possibility just came up, but I'm not certain about the crown angle being too shallow.

Depth - 60.4%
Table - 57%
Crown - 33
Pavilion - 40.8

Any advice, comments are appreciated.