Recommendations in Columbus, Ohio?

[sherpagirl]

We have been considering buying an e-ring and/or diamond wedding band online, and have looked at GOG, Whiteflash. I live in Columbus, Ohio and have not really explored what the city local jewelers may have to offer, and not really sure where to start. We have a Tiffany's, and other "chains" like Kay, Jared, etc, as well as several local places. Does anyone who is familiar with the area have recommendations on where to go to both check out inventory/options for both browsing and possibly purchasing? Are there pros and cons with going with the online option vs. buying in person? Thanks!