Question for Vatche comfort fit X-prong owners

[Sue16]

Hi,

I''m in the process of purchasing a diamond and setting from Good Old Gold. I decided on getting the Vatche comfort fit xprong as my setting. However, I don''t know what size to get. I was told by one jeweler that the comfort fit should be sized down due to the roundness of the band. I went to a different jeweler and he said that I should order my regular size. I''m a size 4.5 and was wondering if I should get a 4.25.

For all you Vatche owners, did you purchase your regular size or did you size down?

Thanks