Quest Jewelers Oval Opinions

[CBurby]

Can you all tell me which stone you like the most? I would like to set this stone East and West, so that''s why I want it a little wide. I also want the color between G-J and between VS1-SI1.

Thanks

1) http://www.questjewelers.com/diamonds.cfm?cmd=stoneDetails&number=128-671&cut=none

2) http://www.questjewelers.com/diamonds.cfm?cmd=stoneDetails&number=128-583&cut=none
this one has strong flouresence

 

[Gypsy]

I like the J in terms of numbers-- but wouldn''t get a J in an oval. Would show too much color for me personally.

The G is a little deep and is skinnier. And SB FL is something you have to see in person to see if you like it.

I like Mark''s oval better. Personally.

 

[CBurby]

Me too, I thought the oval that Mark found for me was great. It just got me worried when the jeweler told me it wasn''t a good diamond. When I spoke with Jim at James Allen, he told me he couldn''t find me anything better than what Mark had gotten me.

 

[Gypsy]

Christian. Don''t listen to the BM. Get the diamond. See for yourself. You don''t like it? Return it. End of story. But you''re going to love it. The numbers aren''t everything... especially with ovals.