Proposing soon, please help with ring!

[taylormccarthy]

So I decided to get an engagement ring from diamonds direct (they're throwing in a free matching wedding band for the 4th of July) but I'm stuck between these three. Which do you think looks like overall better quality?

https://diamondsdirect.com/jeff-cooper-talya-R-3266.html

https://diamondsdirect.com/a-jaffe-seasons-of-love-MES563.html

https://diamondsdirect.com/jeff-cooper-taylor-R-3271.html

 

[motownmama]

I don't know anything about that store, but since it sorta sounds like you're choosing the ring as a surprise (or do you have input?) - I'd choose the first Jeff Cooper. More of a crowd pleaser IMO.

 

[tyty333]

So I decided to get an engagement ring from diamonds direct (they're throwing in a free matching wedding band for the 4th of July) but I'm stuck between these three. Which do you think looks like overall better quality?

https://diamondsdirect.com/jeff-cooper-talya-R-3266.html
Very nice setting that most will love. Dont let them set the stone as high as it is in the picture though.

https://diamondsdirect.com/a-jaffe-seasons-of-love-MES563.html
This ring has an an an, interesting gallery? Some people will love it, some will hate it (mostly hate I think). Skip this setting if it's a surprise.

https://diamondsdirect.com/jeff-cooper-taylor-R-3271.html
If it's a round stone stick with the talya. If it is a square stone you could decide to do either this or the talya.

The quality is good on both ajaffe and jeff cooper settings. Shouldnt be an issue.

 

[lovedogs]

Has your GF expressed any specific preferences, or is this a total surprise? If it's a surprise I totally agree with Tyty and motown that you should stick with the Talya. Very classic and something almost everyone will think is great. However, I'm in the (probable) minority when I say that I totally love the A.Jaffe one. But unless she pointed that one out (or something very similar), I would avoid something so "different" since many people won't like it.

 

[SparkleBabyNYC]

Have you considered other vendors? Diamonds Direct has a lot of great sparkly things but they are overpriced compared to other PS vendors.

 

[Gypsy]

Tayla is best among those. But you are paying too much. And it is set too high.