Princess Choice(s)

[CJ1]

Down to two. What do y''all think. #1 or #2? They both look great!

CJ-

#1.
EGL USA Cert 10/2003
Princess
1.30 CT
VS2
G Color
72% Table
68.6% Depth
Girdle Thin to Medium polished
Culet None
Polish Very Good
Symmetry Very Good
Fluorescence Faint
Crown 9.8%
Pavillion 56.7%
6.16 x 6.15 x 4.22

#2.
GIA Cert
Princess
1.23 CT
VS1
F Color
68% Table
67.8% Depth
Girdle Medium to Slightly Thick
Culet None
Polish Excellent
Symmetry Very Good
Fluorescence None
Crown 8.5%
Pavillion 57.5%
6.14 x 6.09 x 4.13

Thanks again!

 

[cmcwill]

Hi CJ!
I would go with number 2. Its a much better color and better clarity...not that different in size. Better table: depth ratio. It scores a 1A on the AGA chart! The other scores a 2A which is great too! But the first one has a better polish. Number 1 has a better crown...but maybe the sparkle isnt too differnt between the two. Either way, your getting a pretty stone! Is there a large difference in the price? Also, I've been picking up on threads that note the difference in an EGL cert from a GIA cert and that EGL can be off. However I'm not familiar with this at all so maybe do a search for EGL while youre here.

Colleen

 

[Uncle Marty]

Is this a test??? Do I get a prize ?

#2 is the better Diamond.

Because you didn't post the price I would guess the price is similar.

Buy the GIA graded Diamond.

GIA is tougher on the clarity grade. If you have the money and the time bring the GIA Diamond to EGL USA and compare.

Uncle Marty of course

 

[CJ1]

No prize unfortunately

Prices are similar with #2 being slightly more. #1 is EGL USA New York. Thanks for your input everyone! Anyone else? Thanks again!!!

CJ-