shape
carat
color
clarity

LiW Potential Paris Proposal....RUINED???

FuturePsyD

Shiny_Rock
Joined
Aug 17, 2010
Messages
309
Hi Ladies,

Hope you all had a wonderful weekend. I wanted to vent a little and hopefully get some advice and opinions on my situation.
My bf and I got into a bit of an argument this weekend (not over engagement, rings, propsal, etc). In my moment of anger I said, just forget it we can't get along, I give up. Of course I was being immature and I really don't want to break up with him, I was just so frustrated and he was not understanding me or my feelings at ALL. This argument was followed by several more conversations, during one of which he blurted out, well you just ruined everything, I was doing everything I could to get your ring and propose while we were in Paris in March, but I guess thats not going to happen now since you broke up with me (we recently began planning a trip out there).
Evidently, in the heat of our argument, we both said things that we didn't want to say. We are not broken up and he really regrets saying anything.

The entire 5 years we've been together, he's known that I want to go to Paris. The past year we have been ring shopping and getting serious about becoming engaged, so he figured what better place than to propose in Paris. Of course I dreamt that a proposal may happen there but due to the cost of the trip, I didn't want to get my hopes up that he would also be able to afford my dream ring on top of it. I hoped, BUT I certainly wasn't convinced! His job hasn't been stable this past year (he's in marketing and the economy has REALLY affected that line of work) so I knew that if I wanted my dream ring, I may be in for a bit of wait. We both decided that for us, its worth the wait. So never did I dream that we would go to Paris AND for him to be able to save enough to get the ring as well. It's not like it was set in stone, because he did say that he was TRYING to make that happen. But even the fact that it was potentially possible is a big deal in my eyes. I felt, ok well at least I know he's really trying!

So, obviously, the cat is out of the bag now and the element of surprise is gone. However, my biggest concern is that IF he is able to get the ring before our trip, will he decide to NOT propose in Paris since he will think that I am expecting it? He's really big on wanting to surprise me and now I fear that my dream proposal may not happen because he would rather surprise me and do it some place much less desirable. For me, having the Paris proposal is much more important than being completely "surprised". I'm just scared now of getting my hopes up only to be left extremely disappointed. I'd like if you ladies could give me advice on how I should proceed from here and if I should say anything or just let it play out on its own and see if he brings it up to gauge my feelings on the matter?

Thank you & sorry so long!!
 
oh no :( anyway...once your BF does propose, however/wherever it is will be PERFECT. I would just let him do it how he wants and be surprised :) and it might even be in Paris!
 
***hugs***

It will all work out. In a few months, you'll look back at this and laugh...
 
Guys are pro's at blurting these things out at inopportune moments.

My advice is to not to say anything about it again. Let him feel like you are still not sure whether he is going to do it or not. HOLD YOUR TONGUE if ever you feel like bringing it up :P let him feel like he said "well you have blown it now" so he still has some element of surprise when it does happen.

I doubt anyone could pass up a Paris proposal even if its not all a surprise.

Also let it be a lesson, you shouldn't play with his feelings by pretending to break up with him. He obviously thought you were serious!! Imagine how much that would have hurt him.
 
I'm so sorry. I wouldn't say anything. Let him think you've given up on the Paris proposal so he'll think you're not expecting it and he might still do it. Also, I must say, in the moment the location won't even matter. No matter where you are when he proposes all you'll be focused on is him.
 
Thanks for the support! :))

I think I'm going to listen to you ladies and just hold my tongue and follow his lead.

Although proposing on the trip would be lovely, I do agree that wherever it ends up happening will be wonderful as well because it will finally be HAPPENING!!! I just wanted him to know that the "surprise" part isn't as big a deal to me as it is to him. So like you all said, if I don't bring it up, hopefully he will think I just let it go as being "ruined" and feel good about recapturing some of the surprise element.

PrincessNatalie: you're so right! I definitely should not have overreacted and "broken up." Next time I'm that frustrated I will try to control my emotions and think back to the negative consequences! :oops:
 
FuturePsyD said:
I'd like if you ladies could give me advice on how I should proceed from here and if I should say anything or just let it play out on its own and see if he brings it up to gauge my feelings on the matter?

Consider this incident a lesson learned and act accordingly. Rather than focus on a proposal, you should proceed by discussing communication strategies and fighting fair on both of your parts. The rest of your life will unfold from there.
 
Sorry you had such a rough night with an arguement like that. :(
I'd have to agree with the others- keep quiet on the subject. He wants to surprise you and he still will. Whether it's in Paris, or he catches you off guard the night before- it's still going to be amazing. Also, if it happens in Paris- you won't know when or how, so there still is the element of surprise.
 
Thanks for your advice Mary Poppins and Peach Tea.

Mary: I do agree with you, we certainly need to work on our communication skills. It would be for the benefit of our relationship and make our lives much easier.

Peach Tea: Thanks, I'm sure you are also right. It's very possible for it to still happen while we are away, especially if I keep my silence for the next 6 mths. If not I'm sure the moment will still be lovely and we can celebrate while we are on vacation!

Thanks again! :))
 
The same thing happened to me as well. We both said some things in the heat of the moment and he blurted out the day he wanted to engage me! At first I was MAD! but.. then.. I calmed down.. He said he would change my entire date around and everything just to make me happy. I admit, I was the selfish one during the argument. He said we were getting engaged on my graduation party day. That just made me more livid.

So.. 3 weeks later.. he keeps throwing me off, I figured he was changing the date.. thought it would be sooner than later.. Nothing.. tells me not to get my nails done, wishes my ring was done so we could get engaged.. everything you can think of, he probably said to throw me off...

The day of my graduation party, before everyone comes, he asks! He wanted me to think he was changing the date, but he had a date in mind and he was sticking to it! So... do not count out Paris as of yet! :)) *Dust*
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top