Poor Student-Ascher Decision

[ascherHELP]

Hello---I have a choice to make between two different, supposed Ascher cut diamonds. Being that I am only a poor college student I have a limited budget of around 3700. Here are the specs for each of the diamonds and they are both GIA-GTL...any help or advice would be greatly appreciated...thanks!!!

Diamond 1 3600
Shape and cutting style.....Cut-cornered square step-cut
Measurements...5.53x5.43x3.76
Weight...1.00 carat
Depth...69.1%
Table...71%
Girdle...Med
Cutlet...None
Polish...Excellent
Symmetry...Very Good
Clarity...VS2
Color...I
Fluor...None

Diamond 2 3400
Shape and cutting style.....Square Emerald Cut
Measurements...5.70x5.61x4.04
Weight...1.01 carat
Depth...72%
Table...61%
Girdle...Thick
Cutlet...None
Polish...Excellent
Symmetry...Very Good
Clarity...VS1
Color...I
Fluor...None

 

[strmrdr]

forget the first one blech.

The second might be ok but need pictures.

 

[Kaleigh]

I''d look at www.goodoldgold.com . I haven''t looked lately but bought a gorgeous .92 E VS1 assscher that I am just thrilled with. Get pics of the second stone for sure. Good luck!!!