Poll: to rhodium dip or not?

[nala]

Hello all,
First I want to thank all you lovely PSer's who participate in my polls. Although I know it always comes down to personal taste, I enjoying hearing others' opinions.
So here goes. For Xmas, I got this band:
thinking that it would work well with my E-ring. Here is how it looks:


Now, I'm not so sure that it works. I know that both rings are different styles, but I wanted to give the band a shot. So now I have to decide if it's the color that doesn't work well or if it's the style. If it's the color, then I need to rhodium dip it white, but I'm concerned that I won't love it as much because something about the yellow gold really makes these stones pop. I could just wear it as a right hand ring, but if that would be the case, I keep thinking that I should have gotten this one instead:

 

[dk168]

What about keeping it as it is as a RHR, and get another band in white metal to wear with the e-ring?

DK

 

[msop04]

I think it would look best in white metal, but I would worry that you would have to have it redipped... a lot... and often. I agree with the idea to move it to a RHR.

 

[telephone89]

I don't think it 'goes' with your ering, however I dont think dipping it would change that. I'd keep it as is and wear on the rh.

 

[LLJsmom]

I don't think it 'goes' with your ering, however I dont think dipping it would change that. I'd keep it as is and wear on the rh.

+1

 

[doberman]

I don't think it complements your e-ring at all, I will be honest. Can you exchange it for something more in keeping with your ring style?

 

[nala]

Thanks for the input. I have to agree that it doesn't work with my ring. So now I have to decide if it's a keeper. Do you guys think that this band looks good stacked with another eternity, or does the stacking detract--the stacking would be as a right hand ring, of course. I will try to post a picture soon.

 

[nala]

Here are my stacking options. I don't know if they distract or enhance?

 

[maccers]

I think it works really well as a stack! Very interesting combination.

 

[junebug17]

Nala, I think it looks beautiful as a stack! I like the look of the 2 different metals, and each ring stands out on its own, really pretty!

 

[telephone89]

Love it in the stack!

 

[Rena7]

I love it as a stack, I think it's a keeper.

 

[Asscherhalo_lover]

I like it as is in a stack. I also stack yellow gold and white gold/plat bands and I love the look that way.

 

[KaeKae]

While I don't like it with your ering, I love it in the stack. Mixing metals there only gives each ring more interest, I think.

 

[msop04]

Oooohhhh!!! I like it in the stack!!

 

[LuvTheGlitter]

Ditto to everyone else. Not liking it with your e-ring, but LOVING it as a stack on the right hand! Especially the 3 ring stack

 

[Calliecake]

Ditto to everyone else. Not liking it with your e-ring, but LOVING it as a stack on the right hand! Especially the 3 ring stack

+100 It looks so pretty in the three stack. I also love the other band you were considering purchasing.

 

[thecat]

I love it as a stack too!

 

[motownmama]

Ok, well I'm an outlier. I love how it looks with your ER!!!!!!!

 

[Mayk]

Love the RH stack! What size is you MRB eternity? Love it!

 

[Bonfire]

I would leave it as it is. I really loved the delicate band you posted with your e-ring a little while back. It looks perfect with it. Your e-ring needs to be the star and IMO these bigger bands detract from it.

 

[Bonfire]

Here it is. This to me is perfection! Wear the other in a RHR stack, it's lovely!

 

[LuvTheGlitter]

Oh yes, wear the band Bonfire posted a pic of!

 

[nala]

Love the RH stack! What size is you MRB eternity? Love it!

Thank you! It is a size 6 and is made up of .10 carat stones as it measures 3 mm wide.

BonfireI suppose that I should have clarified that I do still wear that antique band. But like the good PSer that I am, I just looove to switch it up every so often. I'm fairly certain that I will keep this band as is--I can't bring myself to tamper with the rich yellow gold, and I think that everyone agrees it works well in the stack.

Thanks to everyone for your input! Even though I still love the other asscher band, I love to stack on my right hand, and the other band does not stack as well because it's not an eternity and the diamonds seem so fragile, as they are prong set. So I guess for now, this one is a keeper!