Pls help me decide between these 2 diamonds

[Phoenix]

Which one of these pear-shaped diamonds would you choose:

1) a fancy intense yellow diamond, measurements 10.93 x7.28x4. 82 . Beautiful deep yellow colour but clarity i1, possibly not eye-clean, but the black crystals are not huge, they're more like dots. From the pic the vendor sent me, I can see some in the table but apparently there are some on the side which I can't see.

2) an E colour (with strong blue fluor - haven't asked if there's any negative impact, but let's just assume for the purpose of this pole that it has no negative impact), SI2 clarity, with measurements 11.20 x8.12x5.26. Seems very sparkling (possibly more sparkling than option 1) . The black crystals (not sure if eye-clean, but do not appear to be big enough to not be eye-clean) are in any case on the side.

There is an $8k approx difference in prices but again let's assume for the time being that I would not make my decision based on the price difference.

Both of these online vendors have the same upgrade policy. Both stones are very roughly about the same carat weight, give or take 0.20ct.

I am thinking of putting it into a very delicate halo, like the HW's or Firegoddess'

Which one would you choose? Thank you.

 

[Lorelei]

I know the fancy colour will be priced by the intensity and quality of the colour, but with the E colour pear, could you get some pics Phoenix?

 

[diamondseeker2006]

If it''s for a right hand ring, then I think it would be nice to have a fancy yellow. But I personally could not handle I1 clarity. I''d rather have a smaller one with better clarity.

I''d consider the other as long as it was 100% eyeclean and an excellent cut.

 

[Ice Princess Cristy]

I love the fancy colored diamonds, but would hesitate if it was not eye clean. I really notice when diamonds are not eye clean or have clouds, etc.