Pls. Help me Choose! (With Pics!)

[subkey]

Hi all,

Which do you like best between these 3 diamonds?

This is 1/3:

1.37 I SI1
61.9 depth
57 table
35.5 crown
40.8 pavilion
Ex/Ex polish/sym
GIA cert
$6650

At a brick & mortar store, this pic came from my idealoscope.

Next diamonds to follow...

 

[subkey]

2/3:

1.3 H SI1
61 depth
54 table
unknown crown/pavilion (2005 GIA cert)
Ex/Ex polish/sym
GIA cert
$7880

Internet store

 

[subkey]

3/3:

1.32 I VVS2
57 depth
61.7 table
34.8 crown
40.8 pavilion
Id/Id polish/sym
AGS cert
$8410.33

Internet store

I know it''s kind of a wide price range... but interested in your thoughts as to whether it''s worth the $$ for the more expensive ones - and worth the risk of buying from an online vendor. It will be in a platinum solitaire setting.

Thanks so much!

 

[subkey]

Any thoughts?

 

[Lorelei]

Hi Subkey!

The last diamond looks the best to me, very high clarity though, would you rather this than SI1? You could see about getting an Idealscope image for the second diamond and see if you can also get a Sarin report done, this will give the details of the crown and pavillion angles. From the pic it looks possible, but if it was me, I would like to have the above info on it before seriously considering it. From the info given, the last would be my pick so far, unless you could find some more with perhaps lower clarity, or perhaps you don't mind VVS?