Please vote!

[nala]

I'm shopping for THE rhr. Which would you get? My hubby is no help!the upper one I negotiated to 4000 and is estimated at .90 and .80 but I think it's more like .80 and .70 on platinum. The lower one is a .60 center with .15 sides on 14 k but it costs 2800. I hate to talk prices but I figure it's the only wAy to be fair. Please vote and coment!

 

[Acinom]

I voted for the one on top with the tranny and the OEC because it looked amazing on you when you wear it properly
It follows the lines of your hand beautifully and I love the classic elegance. It could also be more wearable as it has less parts sticking out like the other ring.

What is your own idea about both rings?

 

[nala]

I voted for the one on top with the tranny and the OEC because it looked amazing on you when you wear it properly
It follows the lines of your hand beautifully and I love the classic elegance. It could also be more wearable as it has less parts sticking out like the other ring.

What is your own idea about both rings?

That's the thing. I had my heart set on an Edwardian OEC. I set my OMC in the setting but it didn't work. My jeweler is letting me trade in the OMC for either of these at these trade in values. I was trying to sell the OMC but instead it seems easier to trade in. I guess I just want to be sure that this is the one. I can always trade up in the future if I'm not happy. The lower one appealed to me bc it is less expensive and I could get credit for future purchases.

 

[arkieb1]

I like the top one the best out of the two or my vote would be save it and put it towards one larger Old cut that is probably what you really seek....

 

[dk168]

Regardless of price, I prefer the look and style of the first one.

Thanks for sharing!

DK

 

[Missy]

Top one! Though I love them both on you Nala. The top one just looks better on you IMO. Talk about finger coverage WOW.

 

[Catmom]

If it were me I would get the top one. I just love the style and it looks wonderful on you. The bottom one just doesn't call out to me like the top one.

 

[Acinom]

I voted for the one on top with the tranny and the OEC because it looked amazing on you when you wear it properly
It follows the lines of your hand beautifully and I love the classic elegance. It could also be more wearable as it has less parts sticking out like the other ring.

What is your own idea about both rings?

That's the thing. I had my heart set on an Edwardian OEC. I set my OMC in the setting but it didn't work. My jeweler is letting me trade in the OMC for either of these at these trade in values. I was trying to sell the OMC but instead it seems easier to trade in. I guess I just want to be sure that this is the one. I can always trade up in the future if I'm not happy. The lower one appealed to me bc it is less expensive and I could get credit for future purchases.

Hi Nala
Based on your reply I wonder whether you really have your heart set on any of these? In that case I second Arkiebs recommendation to take the store credit and save up for a large stone or the RHR ring of your dreams.

 

[nala]

I voted for the one on top with the tranny and the OEC because it looked amazing on you when you wear it properly
It follows the lines of your hand beautifully and I love the classic elegance. It could also be more wearable as it has less parts sticking out like the other ring.

What is your own idea about both rings?

That's the thing. I had my heart set on an Edwardian OEC. I set my OMC in the setting but it didn't work. My jeweler is letting me trade in the OMC for either of these at these trade in values. I was trying to sell the OMC but instead it seems easier to trade in. I guess I just want to be sure that this is the one. I can always trade up in the future if I'm not happy. The lower one appealed to me bc it is less expensive and I could get credit for future purchases.

[/quote



Based on your reply I wonder whether you really have your heart set on any of these? In that case I second Arkiebs recommendation to take the store credit and save up for a large stone or the RHR ring of your dreams.[/


The irony is that the OEC of my dreams reminds me too much of another ering. I never quite feel comfortable wearing what to me feels like 2 Erings, which is why I originally reset my OMC which looked gorgeous in its yellow halo. I never wore it. Rotating rings is not an Option, that is what I'm sure of,
so the more I think about it, the more that I appreciate this moi et toi ring. At some point, I had even considered creating my own with my two OMC. I think that its taken me a while to realize that the dream ring is impractical and that this style works better in my life bc I plan to wear it a lot and not let it just sit in my box. This poll has helped me realize that the less expensive one is not as beautiful and has clarified my thoughts since my hubby kept telling me they both looked the same to him.

 

[nala]

I just wanted to THANK all of you who took the time to vote and to comment! I actually purchased the one on the upper picture and am really enjoying it! I've been wearing it on my right hand finger and it is so comfy and so sparkly!

 

[junebug17]

That's great nala!! So glad you're enjoying it, it's a gorgeous ring!

 

[nala]

That's great nala!! So glad you're enjoying it, it's a gorgeous ring!

Thank you!

 

[ccuheartnurse]

Congratulations, it's very pretty.
Judy

 

[thecat]

I just wanted to THANK all of you who took the time to vote and to comment! I actually purchased the one on the upper picture and am really enjoying it! I've been wearing it on my right hand finger and it is so comfy and so sparkly!

That would have been my choice as well. Glad that you're enjoying it!

 

[CRYSTAL24K]

Yay! The upper one would have been my choice also! Enjoy it. It looks great on you! I would like to see more pics of it if you have any.