Please I need an opinion with diamonds

[jhk79]

Hi. I am very new to all this diamond thing, but I''m planning to propose to my gf and have been researching some. I need your input as to which one is a better diamond. Also, is there a big difference b/w a G color and a H color? Is it worth to pay a little more to get the G instead of the H? Thank you.


Option 1

Option 2

 

[honey22]

You have picked two stunning diamonds there!! Well done

ACAs are great cuts, and well cut stones will hide colour more. You are not going to see any tint of colour in a H stone, and it should face up beautifully. We see many gorgeous ACAs here, even J and I colour still facing up nice and white. You shouldn''t have a problem at all.

You are splitting hairs over those two stones, they will both be equally gorgeous. I would lean towards the cheaper one though, just to save a few $$$. You could always give WF a call and ask Brian to look at both stones and pick his preference.

Don''t forget to ask for the PS discount, you will get a small discount of the stones, I believe you have to pay by bank wire only though (not 100% sure).

 

[Lorelei]

Date: 9/24/2008 2:00:23 AM
Author: honey22
You have picked two stunning diamonds there!! Well done

ACAs are great cuts, and well cut stones will hide colour more. You are not going to see any tint of colour in a H stone, and it should face up beautifully. We see many gorgeous ACAs here, even J and I colour still facing up nice and white. You shouldn''t have a problem at all.

You are splitting hairs over those two stones, they will both be equally gorgeous. I would lean towards the cheaper one though, just to save a few $$$. You could always give WF a call and ask Brian to look at both stones and pick his preference.

Don''t forget to ask for the PS discount, you will get a small discount of the stones, I believe you have to pay by bank wire only though (not 100% sure).

Ditto, that could help you decide.

 

[jhk79]

Thank you for your inputs. I''ll try giving WF a call.

 

[JoeNewbie11]

I''d drop in Clarity to VS2 or even SI1 in that carat weight IMHO and get a larger stone...

You could go up to 1.35 Carat if you drop in clarity...
http://www.whiteflash.com/hearts_arrows/A-Cut-Above-H-A-cut-diamond-1466971.htm