Please Help with Two Diamonds

[cmnalo]

Hi, I was wondering if anyone could help me with which of these two diamonds would be better.

Shape Round Round
Carat 1.03 1
Color I I
Clarity VS2 VS2
Measurements 6.46-6.52X3.95 6.33-6.36X3.98
Table % 58 55
Depth % 60.9 62.7
Polish Very Good Very Good
Symmetry Very Good Very Good
Girdle M-S TK, F M-TK
Culet None Small
Fluorescence No No
Certificate GIA GIA
Sarin Report
IdealScope Report
Bag

 

[Maxine]

Do you have any more information????? The second one is somewhat deep, and has weight in the girdle -
Are these local to you or online.....
Do you mind sharing your budget? You might be able to get good cut parameters within your budget by "playing" with some of the other parameters on the search by cut search engine (ie: you might be able to get the same size, really well cut stone for the same price if you look at SI1 stones...just a thought).

 

[cmnalo]

Thank you for writing back. These two were found on Whiteflash''s site. I am helping my best friends boyfriend find her a ring and I think he wants to stay in the low $4000 for the stone.

 

[Maxine]

They could call whiteflash and ask about the stones......here is one they have in-house....but it''s a J, SI1........Many poeple here are very happy with J''s if they are well cut!!!!http://whiteflash.com/diamonds/diamond_Detail.aspx?itemcode=GIA-13697002#

Also, if you look for something just UNDER a carat, you might be able to find something more affordable, at almost the same size........

 

[Maxine]

try again: http://whiteflash.com/diamonds/diamond_Details.aspx?itemcode=GIA13697002

 

[Regular Guy]

Date: 5/21/2005 1:09:58 PM
Author: Maxine
They could call whiteflash and ask about the stones......here is one they have in-house....but it''s a J, SI1........Many poeple here are very happy with J''s if they are well cut!!!!http://whiteflash.com/diamonds/diamond_Detail.aspx?itemcode=GIA-13697002#

Also, if you look for something just UNDER a carat, you might be able to find something more affordable, at almost the same size........

Maxine, I couldn''t bring up the one you found, but it might have been this one you were going for.

Justine, would suggest you review the tutorial here under Knowledge above, and while not sure about either of the ones you''ve identified...you might try to ask WF''s help, looking at the one or both of them against this other one, and get their advice as to which is better.

For more background, see the link below my signature.

Best!

 

[Maxine]

That was it, RG!!!!!!