Please Help!!! Which diamond should I choose?

[jwvu]

I am buying an engagement ring this week and would like help buying the best diamond. Which two diamonds from this list would you all choose.

Diamond #1

1.80, J/SI2, Polish-VG, Sym-VG, Fl-Very Slight, 60%depth, 56%table, 7.88mm for $9504

#2

1.53, I/SI2, Polish-VG, Sym-VG, Fl-None, 60% depth, 58% table, 7.46mm for $8568

#3

1.52, I/SI1, Polish-VG, Sym-VG, Fl-None, 60.5%depth, 57%table, 7.49mm for $8598

#4

1.50, I/VS2, Polish-VG, Sym-VG, Fl-I dont remember, 58% depth, 58% table, 7.59mm for 8750

#5

1.73, F/SI2, Polish-Ex, Sym-VG, Fl-?, 61.8% depth, 53 or 55% table, 7.71mm for 10,450

 

[jaz464]

What shape are these?

 

[belle]

not enough information here to make any assumptions.
have you seen these stones?