Please help me to choose one of these 2 diamond

[Johnl]

Please help me to take a look the spec of below diamonds. Which cutting is better? And looks more brilliant. I am not concern about clarity.

Thanks a lot.
1.
1.23 carat E color VS2 GIA 3EX
Table: 56%
Depth: 61.9%
Crown angle: 35.0
Pavilion Angle: 40.8
Crown %: 15.5
Pavilion %: 43%
Fluorescence:None
Girdle Thickness: medium(faceted) 3.5%
Star Facet Length Percentage: 50%
Lower Girdle Facet Percentage: 80%
HCA: 1.6
Price: CAD$12,400



2. 1.21 carat E color VVS2 GIA 3EX

Table: 57%
Depth: 61.3%
Crown angle: 34.5
Pavilion Angle: 40.8
Crown %: 15.0%
Pavilion %: 43%
Fluorescence:None
Girdle Thickness: medium to slight thick
Star Facet Length Percentage: 55%
Lower Girdle Facet Percentage: 80%
hca: 1.4
Price: $13,400

 

[iammariaberg]

I think, you should go with 1st one

 

[Gypsy]

Both are nice. Have you seen them in person or will you have a chance to?

 

[Johannes89]

by the number alone id go with the 2nd ... then again there shouldnt be a big difference.
Is it worth the 1k extra? i doubt it.
So if money is a factor which it usually is id prolly go for the first afterall^^
performance alone as i said id prefer the 2nd by numbers but also keep in mind is and aset might tell a different story.

 

[Johnl]

I cannot see these 2 diamonds in person. All I know is the numbers above. I did some research online. I am a little worry about the 35 degree crown angle on 1st diamond. The 2nd diamond crown/pavilion angle 34.5/40.8 looks perfect, also 61.3% depth might be better than 61.9%. But first diamond table 56% might be better. I am not sure which value ( table/depth/crown angle) is more important compare with these 2 diamonds.

 

[Johnl]

by the number alone id go with the 2nd ... then again there shouldnt be a big difference.
Is it worth the 1k extra? i doubt it.
So if money is a factor which it usually is id prolly go for the first afterall^^
performance alone as i said id prefer the 2nd by numbers but also keep in mind is and aset might tell a different story.

Yes, money is a factor. But I want the diamond has great fire sparkle since it's already $12,000+.