Please help me decide on all 3 diamonds with sta F, Vs1, XXX

[ninalodes]

Here are the diamonds and my concern with each. All cost around $30k
1. Gia #5186328669
- Extra facet
- HCA 2.5
2. Gia #1189026855
- Slightly big pavvilion angle
- HCA 1.3
3. GIA #1199238641
- Small diameter 7.96 - 8.01 (As if it is a 1.95 carat)
- HCA 1.9

4. GIA #2161993706
- Depth is smaller than table, might losse light return
- HCA 2.0

All your comment and opinion are greatly appreciated. Which one might have better resale value? Thanks

 

[Paul-Antwerp]

Re: Please help me decide on all 3 diamonds with sta F, Vs1,

Hi Barbie,

Weird to see that your question did not get replies.

As a cutter, I am not going to comment into depth about the quality of your choices. They are all relatively similar and probably an indication of where you put your priorities.

With regards to resale-value, that is hard to predict. May I answer by telling you what my standing offer is on these stones, without actually having seen them? It may be indicative for you.

In fact, my offer on the first three stones is the same, at $17,600.-. The 4th stone however, I value a little bit lower, $17,000.-

Hope this helps.

Best regards,