PLEASE HELP ME CHOOSE THE BEST : )

[tac1130]

OK ... these are all GIA gertified.

2.02 carats
E color
SI 2
polish very good
symmetry excellent
table 59%
depth 60.3%
measurements 8.15 - 8.19 - 4.93

OR...

2.00 CARATS
E color
SI 2
polish excellent
symmetry very good
depth 61%
table 57%
8.04-8.08-4.92


or...

2.09 carats
cut excellent
polish excellent
symmatry excellent
F color
Si 1
table 57%
depth 62.2 %
8.08- 8.15- 5.05


PLEASE HELP!

 

[dmus]

Everyone around here will want to see the other measurements such as crown and pav angles and any ASETs or Isealsopes if you have them. It''s all about cut. And by the way, are these eyeclean?

 

[tac1130]

yes very eve clean but i really do not know the other dementions...

 

[sapient007]

first of all, i''m a noob but i''ll take a stab at saying this is the best stone with what you''ve provided and assuming all the same price b/c of the cut and polish + a larger table so should be more sparkle?? ~shrivels back to the cave and waiting for better answers

2.09 carats
cut excellent
polish excellent
symmatry excellent
F color
Si 1
table 57%
depth 62.2 %
8.08- 8.15- 5.05

 

[dmus]

Thatr makes it tough. Have you seen these in person? If you can''t get any more info and still want to go forward make sure you can return if not satisfied and have it appraised inependently.

Based on the limited info I lean towards the second diamond. The table is smaller and the depth is not too deep. You won''t know how light perforance is until you get it and even then you should compare to other diamonds of comparable qauility to better evaluaste.

Can''t you get a copy of the GIA cert? those usually have other measurements.

 

[mercoledi]

If you have the GIA certificate numbers, you can look up the crown and pavilion angles online.

 

[tac1130]

ok i will try to get the copies today thank you

 

[heb1976]

What you can do is just call and ask for the report numbers and look them up online.

http://www.gia.edu/reportcheck/