Please help me choose one of these two diamonds

[Joshyss]

I am trying to decide which of these two diamonds to buy. They are both within about a couple hundred dollars each so price isn't a worry. I just want to pick the better of the two. The first one I have a picture of, it's an F SI1 and is 1.00 Ct in size. GIA report is here:

http://www.gia.edu/otmm_wcs_int/pro...rtCheckPOC/pocservlet?ReportNumber=2145747782


The second is a G SI1 1.11 Ct in size and the GIA report is here:

http://www.gia.edu/otmm_wcs_int/pro...rtCheckPOC/pocservlet?ReportNumber=2146952402

I don't know how to upload pictures from my iPhone though?

Please help me pick the better stone... Both are, as I'm told from the vendors, eye clean.

Thank you in advance.

 

[Niel]

i cant seem to get the certs to pull up. What are the GIA numbers? also, what are they asking for those stoneS?

 

[Christina...]

Can you get an ideal scope image for either of these stones?

 

[Joshyss]

Thanks for the replies. The stones are ~$7000 each. The GIA report numbers are F stone 2145747782 and the g stone is 2146952402. Ideals cope would be better to go off I know but is hard to get from them.

 

[Joshyss]

This is the F stone

 

[Joshyss]

This is also the F stone

 

[Niel]

id pick the F, the table was a bit big, but its a nice depth so itll face up large

 

[JulieN]

ASET seems to suggest it is a little bit shallow, but shouldn't be a problem.

 

[Joshyss]

The F stone gets a score of 1.4 and the G stone gets 1.9 on HCA

 

[Christina...]

The F stone gets a score of 1.4 and the G stone gets 1.9 on HCA

HCA is pass fail, below 2 is a pass, over 2 fail. A 1.4 doesn't mean that it performs better than a 1.9 so you can't make a determination based that alone. Can you get the same images for the G?