Please help me choose between a few different rocks

[RedSpikeyThing]

Thanks for taking the time to read my post!

I'm looking for some input on which of these round diamonds to purchase. I'm looking at spending ~$7100 CAD (~$5700 USD) on the diamond and am willing to spend a bit more if there is a particularly good deal for a bit more.

What I'm looking for:
Shape: round
cut: ideal or better
Carat: ~1.0-1.15
Color: H or better
Clarity: SI1 or better

I did a bunch of digging on James Allen and came across the rocks below, in the order that I like them. I would love some feedback on what you guys think about these. Is the bigger one worth the extra cost? Or should I get the smaller, cleaner diamond?

1.15 ct, G, SI1. $7397 CAD. This is a good size and looks pretty clean to me.

0.96 ct, G,VVS2, $7116 This one is quite a bit lighter but is a high quality diamond and has a thin girdle which should make it look bigger.

1.00 ct, H, SI1. $6617 CAD A little less clear but significantly cheaper. Is this a good value, or is the extra cost worth the improvement?


If you have the time, any suggestions for other diamonds to consider?

 

[RedSpikeyThing]

Does anyone have any input? Is there more information I can provide that would help? Thanks!

 

[danielxlin]

First two diamonds survive the HCA tool, the final one does not.

First two diamonds have strong fluorescence, the final one does not.

I like how you're choosing, mostly GIA triple excellent, with lower depth percentages for a little extra spread. I guess I'd choose the first one because it's still available (unlike the second), has a low HCA score (unlike the third), and may be a bargain (if JA confirms the fluorescence doesn''t give any milkyness to the diamond in direct sunlight).

I will say the third diamond looks damn lively in JA's picture technology. Ask JA's gemologist what he or she thinks.

 

[RedSpikeyThing]

Thank you very much for your help!
I didn't know about the HCA tool until your comment so I did some more digging through the available diamonds and didn't find any other ones that fit my criteria. I ended up getting the 1.15 ct (first one)