Please Help Choosing a Stone

[ps_stone]

Stone A: E/SI1/Eye Clean 7.49 mm 61.1% dept/ 57% table/ 35 crown / 40.8 pavilion / HCA score 1.6
Stone B: E/SI1/Eye Clean 7.52 mm 61% dept/ 57% table / 34 crown / 40.6 pavilion/ HCA score .7

A has feather, needle, crystal. B has one cloud, crystal, feather. All other specs are the same - ex, ex, ex, no fluorescence.

The price on A is ~$750 more.

Which should I choose based on these info?

Thank you!

 

[Diamond_Hawk]

ps_stone,

The diamonds both show good proportions and (as you have no doubt learned) a good HCA score. We really need access to the grading reports (GIA, AGS, EGL, IGI?) and any scientific images available (ASET or IdealScope) to offer an informed opinion.

Imagine the diamonds were people and you were asking us to tell you if person A or person B were in better shape. You have given us a chalk outline of each person. The Grading reports would be like giving us height and weight and the scientific images would be like getting a picture and body mass index of each person.

Once we have all that information, properly analyzed, we can give you an opinion.

They may both be in great shape, or there may be minor or significant differences.

 

[Niel]

Stone A: E/SI1/Eye Clean 7.49 mm 61.1% dept/ 57% table/ 35 crown / 40.8 pavilion / HCA score 1.6
Stone B: E/SI1/Eye Clean 7.52 mm 61% dept/ 57% table / 34 crown / 40.6 pavilion/ HCA score .7

A has feather, needle, crystal. B has one cloud, crystal, feather. All other specs are the same - ex, ex, ex, no fluorescence.

The price on A is ~$750 more.

Which should I choose based on these info?

Thank you!

can we see them?

are you able to get idealscopes?

 

[ps_stone]

There are no other reports available, except for these pictures. I am a newbie and have learned so much on this board, so thank you everyone!

 

[Niel]

im inclined to say A because of the location of the inclusion on b

 

[ps_stone]

Also they both are GIA cert Excellent cut grade.

 

[ps_stone]

Thank you Neil. That was also my thought however should I be concerned about two long needles running along side near the table? Any issues with breakage on needles?

 

[ps_stone]

Faults chart

 

[yellowman]

Any issues with breakage on needles










__________________
Fifa 15 coins

 

[shufu15]

Hello! You write something very interesting! Helpful to me,

Hello! You write something very interesting! Helpful to me, I also find the fun! Thank you!

 

[shufu15]

Hello there! I happened to see you write something, and it h

Hello there! I happened to see you write something, and it helps me a lot, thank you very much!