Please help! Buying tom!

[Glowgirl3]

My gf and I have picked these 2 stones...which would you buy of the two? Going to put the deposit down tomorrow.

1.8 ct, I VS2. A cut above (AGS 0/0/0)
Table = 57.3
Depth = 60.9
Crown = 33.3
Pavillion = 40.8

OR

1.74 ct, G VS2 (GIA Ex/Ex/Ex)
Table = 58
Depth = 60.5
Crown = 33.5
Pavillion = 41


Have to purchase tom for New Year proposal! Please advise

 

[sonnyjane]

Do you have pictures?

 

[Glowgirl3]

This is the 1.8 I VS2.
My friend saw the other one, the G, VS2, and said it had ALMOST equal fire to a hearts and arrows.

 

[diamondseeker2006]

I wouldn't buy the GIA stone without a picture at least and preferably and idealscope image.

I'd like to see the link for the WF stone because I am not seeing a 1.8 I VS2 ACA on their site. And 33.3 is not a crown angle that I usually see on an ACA, either.

 

[Glowgirl3]

Hi!

Thanks for the response. It's actually 33.8, sorry, that was a typo.

It's not showing up cuz I put it on hold. I read stories on here so wanted to be safe.

 

[diamondseeker2006]

Hi!

Thanks for the response. It's actually 33.8, sorry, that was a typo.

It's not showing up cuz I put it on hold. I read stories on here so wanted to be safe.

Oh, okay! Check and see if it is 34.8. I think that is what it should be!

 

[Glowgirl3]

It says 33.8 on the AGS cert.

I did a HCA on it, and it is 1. Bob from WF is SO great, I think I'm going to go with it. Thoughts?