Please give me feedback on these two diamonds...

[ChristineGreco]

Hello all! I'd appreciate any feedback you could give on the following two diamonds. They are very similar... I think... Which would you choose based in these measurements? Does anything stand out I should be aware of? Positive or negative?

Thank you very much!

Round Brilliant
7.16 - 7.20 x 4.49 mm
1.43 carat
H
VS2
Excellent
TBL 57%
TD 62.4%
CA 35.0
PA 40.8
ST 50%
LH 80%
Girdle Med to STK, F (4.0%)
Cutlet Non
Polish Excellent
Symmetry Excellent
Fluorescence None

Round Brilliant
7.20 - 7.22 x 4.47 mm
1.43 carat
H
SI1
Excellent
TBL 57%
TD 62.0%
CA 35.0
PA 40.8
ST 55%
LH 75%
Girdle Med to STK, F (3.5%)
Cutlet Non
Polish Excellent
Symmetry Excellent
Fluorescence None

 

[Gypsy]

Can you get idealscope images?

 

[ChristineGreco]

No... From a jeweler without the means... Any feedback based on these measurements? Thank you!!

 

[Gypsy]

Did you run the HCA on them?

 

[ChristineGreco]

Yes. They both are 1.7.

 

[ChristineGreco]

Hello again... Are they so similar that it's just a choice between a VS2 or SI1 or do the slight measurement differences make one a better choice over the other? Thank you!

 

[Gypsy]

Hello again... Are they so similar that it's just a choice between a VS2 or SI1 or do the slight measurement differences make one a better choice over the other? Thank you!

Yup. That's pretty much it.

 

[ChristineGreco]

Thank you! Appreciate it!

 

[ChristineGreco]

Gypsy,

I read that 62.5% is maximum total depth. Is the TD of 62.4 on the VS2 borderline or perfectly acceptable as long as under 62.5%? Thank you again!

 

[Gypsy]

Yes, 62.4 okay. So you are fine.

 

[ChristineGreco]

Thank you very much!