opinions

[cemrn]

I am trying to learn as much as I can about gemstones between work, kids, life. So basically I am really a gem dummy and relying on the advice of the experts. I am looking at getting a pink tourmaline cut. Is there any rule about color with this stone? Is a certain shade better than another or is it just what appeals to you? What do you think of this color? My stone would be cut from the same rough if I decide to procede.

 

[baby nurse]

Christie, this is a beautiful stone. I believe it's Gene's-- I bought it and should be receiving it this week. I think anything cut from the same rough would be amazing!

ETA I purchased it about a week ago when he first had his sale.

 

[BWise]

Welcome to the color stone family!

Unless you are collecting for resale, most of us will put our own color preference as the #1 rule - you get what you like and there are so many colors to choose from!

Take pink tourmaline for example, it can come in many different shades from baby pink to hot pink. I am no expert on the subject so I will let others chime in. However, do keep in mind that in many cases, pink tourmaline shift color slightly in different lighting. Others may hold the color in all lighting, but you need to make sure to confirm that with the vendor - if that''s what you are going after.

Good luck in your search!

 

[chrono]

We always advice to get what appeals to you but at the same time, you have to understand why one colour is preferred over others and why it costs more. When it comes to pink tourmalines, the more vivid the saturation the better. The second more important point is to be sure the colour doesn’t shift when viewed indoors. Most tourmalines close up, get muddy or turn brownish under incandescent lighting but not all. A good quality pink tourmaline will maintain the same hue both indoors and outdoors.

 

[cemrn]

Date: 6/29/2010 8:20:36 AM
Author: Chrono
We always advice to get what appeals to you but at the same time, you have to understand why one colour is preferred over others and why it costs more. When it comes to pink tourmalines, the more vivid the saturation the better. The second more important point is to be sure the colour doesn’t shift when viewed indoors. Most tourmalines close up, get muddy or turn brownish under incandescent lighting but not all. A good quality pink tourmaline will maintain the same hue both indoors and outdoors.

Good info Chrono. So what do you think of this stone based on the photo? Does it look muddy to you? The photo is pretty close up but can you tell from a photo. Would it be advisable to wait for baby nurse to get her stone from the same rough and see what she thinks of it in different lighting, to make sure it isn''t brownish?

 

[chrono]

I cannot tell from this photograph if the tourmaline will hold its colour because I do not know the lighting condition. Based on the picture alone, the pink tourmaline shows hints of a blue modifier that some may be partial to. What I do know for sure is that Gene is an upstanding vendor who will stand by his policies.

 

[cemrn]

Date: 6/29/2010 8:52:07 AM
Author: Chrono
I cannot tell from this photograph if the tourmaline will hold its colour because I do not know the lighting condition. Based on the picture alone, the pink tourmaline shows hints of a blue modifier that some may be partial to. What I do know for sure is that Gene is an upstanding vendor who will stand by his policies.

OK, should I ask him once the stone is cut to photograph it in different lighting? If so what kind....natural, direct sun? Anyone have an example of a muddy tourmaline for me to see? I had gathered that Gene was trustworthy so I can rely on his opinion of the stone. He had told me his price/carat for this stone would be on his higher range due to the color being good. I plan to speak with him today, I just need to know what to ask so I sound half way educated on the subject

Anyone else want to jump in on this pleeeeease

 

[movie zombie]

the stone appears to me to be a bit "dirty" re color. [eta: i'm also not a pink person] having said that, color stones are very hard to photograph.

and gene is an absolute "gem" to deal with. he is honest about his stones and i believe is very fair in pricing his stones.

remember: you do get what you pay for and there is something for every budget. don't expect a world class stone for beer prices.

and again having said that i don't think one can go wrong in making a first color stone purchase from gene. i note you've educated yourself enough to stay away from e-bay as a beginner: congrats!

please keep us posted, especially post some pictures after you receive the stone.

mz

ps i prefer garnets which have more "life"....and i think gene does a super job with them. think about one for your next purchase.....color stones are addictive!

 

[chrono]

I have example pictures but I can't seem to upload.

ETA
Gene should be able to tell from the rough material itself before it is cut to see if it turns muddy under incandescent lighting.

 

[cemrn]

Thanks I started a new thread because I am a confused mess

 

[chrono]

Since I am unable to post example pictures showing a pink tourmaline that browns out under incandescent lighting, I managed to find a link to it.
https://www.pricescope.com/community/threads/precisiongem-1001-rubellite-tourmaline.138624/page-2

 

[Valentino]

all African pink (nigerian) tourmalines will be mostly brownish under incandescent.
Only Brazilian pinks will have that modfier at

less extend.
Cheers,
Valentino

 

[PrecisionGem]

Valentino, you have not seen enough African tourmaline, or the right ones. You are absolutely wrong.

 

[T L]

Date: 6/29/2010 5:54:46 PM
Author: Valentino
all African pink (nigerian) tourmalines will be mostly brownish under incandescent.
Only Brazilian pinks will have that modfier at

less extend.
Cheers,
Valentino

Valentino,
I disagree. I have four Nigerian pink tourmalines, and they do not shift to brown under any lighting. Also note that some pink tourmaline is treated (I believe irradiated) to a hot pink color.

 

[chictomato]

Date: 6/29/2010 7:38:45 PM
Author: tourmaline_lover

Date: 6/29/2010 5:54:46 PM

Author: Valentino

all African pink (nigerian) tourmalines will be mostly brownish under incandescent.

Only Brazilian pinks will have that modfier at

less extend.

Cheers,

Valentino

Valentino,

I disagree. I have four Nigerian pink tourmalines, and they do not shift to brown under any lighting. Also note that some pink tourmaline is treated (I believe irradiated) to a hot pink color.

Plus 1! I have a Nigeria Rubellite from Gene, it does not shift to brown at all

 

[chrono]

Date: 6/29/2010 5:54:46 PM
Author: Valentino
all African pink (nigerian) tourmalines will be mostly brownish under incandescent.
Only Brazilian pinks will have that modfier at

less extend.
Cheers,
Valentino

I, too, disagree. I own two pink/red tourmalines which do not shift under incandescent light. I returned the third pink tourmaline which browned out indoors. All three are of Nigerian origin.