opinions requested on round H&A''s

[Bill D.]

I decided to evaluate some rounds and I''d like your opinions:

1. 0.85ct/G/VVS2 D:61/T:54.5/CA:34.0/PA:40.9/HCA=1.1

2. 0.90ct/H/VVS1 D:60.9/T:54.5/CA:34.2/PA:40.9/HCA=1.3

3. 0.91ct/F/VS2 D:61/T:55.1/CA:34.4/PA:40.8/HCA=1.1

#2 is $1100 more than #1 and #3 is $900.

My gut is #1.

 

[Bill D.]

Here's an update:

I like #1 a lot. The only concern that I have developed is related to the girdle thickness which is 0.6-1.3%. I'd like to have it set in a 4-prong setting.

Any opinions?