Opinions on two diamonds

[simon-says]

Hello!

I would really appreciate it if some of you could give your opinion on the below two A Cut Above diamonds.

Which one should I choose, if any? They are both similar in price with only a couple hundred dollars difference. A bit over $11k.

Both have the eye clean logo.

I have also attached the AGS reports in PDF format.

Thank you!!

Diamond 1




IDEALSCOPE


ASET


HEARTS



Diamond 2




IDEALSCOPE


ASET


HEARTS

 

[diamondseeker2006]

Both are fabulous diamonds. I would ask which one is the cleanest from the top and sides and decide based on that. They are so well matched that they'd make a great pair of stud earrings!