opinions on a round brilliant please...

[highendgems]

1.52 carat round brilliant
EGL USA certified and re-confirmed by GIA as accurate
H color
VS2 clarity
no flourescense
slightly thin to medium girdle (1.7-3.1%)
EGL ideal cut
polish excellnet
symmetry very good-excellent
depth 61.70%
measurements: 7.44 x 7.40 x 4.56 mm
56% table
40.1 degree angle pavilion
37.0 degree angle crown
no culet

the holloway cut advisor shows this as an ideal top pick (1.0 excellent)...any other opinions would be appreciated, thanks

 

[strmrdr]

From the information given it looks good.
Is it h&a?
See if you can get an ideal-scope image that will confirm its a good one?

 

[diamondsman]

just wondering how was it reconfirmed by g.i.a?
did you actually submit it again to g.i.a and have gotten the same color and clarity??

other than that it looks alike a very nicely made stone.

 

[highendgems]

hi, thanks for the reply. it has an EGL (Dec. 2003 in the USA) cert. and was evaluated and appraised by a certified GIA gemologist as a second opion. the GIA axaminer has been doing this for over 20 years and came up with the same clairty and color as the EGL cert.

 

[diamondsman]

most gemoloist had to go to the g.i.a course in order to become one.
I am just wondering if you sent that stone to g.i.a ,would it get the same results??? and if it will why wasn't it submitted to them in the first place???as dealers can get better prices for g.i.a certs.