opinion on two stones

[griggsy]

from all you experts... can you help me out evaluating these two stones... Thanks
Both are princess cut described as perfect square

Diamond #1 is 1.16 carats, G color, VS-2,
Depth 71.6 Table 73
Pol VG Sym VG
Medium Blue fluorescence
5.89 x 5.80

Diamond #2 is 1.15 carats, H color, VS-1,
Depth 77.4 Table 75
Pol VG Sym VG
no fluorescence

The price seems very good on both these diamonds, what's your opinions.. am I missing anything..
Thanks

Griggsy

 

[Hest88]

Well, both the table and depth are much greater than I''d like to see. The depth especially makes me think neither one will be as lively as you''d like.

 

[griggsy]

I dint know of I should include the prices, but after looking at other forums...

Diamond #1 is 1.16 carats, G color, VS-2, $5,600
Diamond #2 is 1.15 carats, H color, VS-1, $4,500

 

[alexah]

Date: 11/3/2004 3:37:45 PM
Author:griggsy
The price seems very good on both these diamonds, what's your opinions.. am I missing anything..

Hiya griggsy

The price is ok - i wouldn't go so far as to say "very good" tho... esp considering the depth/table of #2. Just as an example, this 1.11 H VS2 "perfect square" is $4200.

 

[griggsy]

BTTT