shape
carat
color
clarity

Non-Cathedral Setting for Round with Tapered Baguettes (or Bullets, etc...)? Help me brainstorm, please.

gemshow

Shiny_Rock
Premium
Joined
Dec 1, 2011
Messages
104
I'm considering whether to pursue a custom setting for my heirloom 4ct round. I love this ring's classic tapered baguette setting style. The goals of creating a new setting would be to respect & recreate with improved proportions and craftsmanship. (Also, since removing/resetting for GIA evaluation, the stone is crooked and snagging, so some action is required. The local jeweler who removed/reset didn't charge for doing so; I will not seek recourse there).

I want to set the center as low as possible, culet nearly scraping my finger. I clean my jewelry daily so dust/oil isn't a concern. I'm picturing an extremely low basket setting for the center, with 4 double-claw prongs designed to give the stone a more cushiony appearance from a distance. I don't want the stone to look like a doorknob on my hand.

I want to keep the same style, but I have a strong preference for non-cathedral settings.

Eliminating the cathedral seems at odds with maintaining the style because:
-baguettes aren't curved, but shanks are (and I don't want bulky, protruding shoulders or excessive metal anywhere), and
-angling tapered baguettes up toward the center stone makes for graceful flow (and mitigates the doorknob effect) when viewed straight on.

I'm brainstorming whether it's possible to recreate this classic style with the above in mind, possibly bezel-set baguettes, or bullets?
I don't want it to look too contemporary, but I do want it to be sleek and streamlined (i.e. no milgrain).

I'm thinking baguettes would have to be short to to sit flat on the shank, if this is possible.

Bullets with a wider flare might work well for this as bullets' shape more closely reflects the taper from center stone to shank.

Photos of current ring:
20250827_142407~2.jpg

3d787290-dc36-4160-a936-680e0647109e-copied-media~2.jpg

20250827_141737.jpg

The underside of the metal holding the baguettes looks rough.
The center stone appears out of alignment with the setting.
Finally, it seems the girdle of this diamond was not bruted under the prongs.
The stone wasn't reset in its original position and now wonky portions of the girdle are exposed.
20250902_135507.jpg


Regarding bezel-set side stones, a quick internet search yielded these designs by Chelsea Knights at Green Lake Jewelry Works.

I'm not saying this is exactly the path I want to take, but it's a good illustration of what is possible:
Green Lake Jewelry Works 121790 (1).jpgGreen Lake Jewelry Works 121790 (2).jpgGreen Lake Jewelry Works 121790 (3) - Copy.jpgGreen Lake Jewelry Works 121790.jpg

Green Lake Jewelry Works 152021 (1).jpgGreen Lake Jewelry Works 52021 (2).jpgGreen Lake Jewelry Works Side 152021 (3).jpgGreen Lake Jewelry Works Angle 152021.jpg
 

Attachments

  • Green Lake Jewelry Works 152021 video.png
    Green Lake Jewelry Works 152021 video.png
    350 KB · Views: 4
I'm continuing to search. I found this "Plunge" style by Frank Darling

I like the profile but I wish the transition between the outer edge of the baguettes and the shank were smoother:
Plunge Frank Darling Untitled.jpg

Frank Darling 146E-CUPL3TByellow_00002.jpg

Frank Darling Plunge Set148E-RDPL3TByellow_00004.webp
 
Victor Canera makes one too, interesting:
"Six Prong Trilogy with Open Profile"
I'm unsure how this would fit and how comfortable it would be:
Six-Prong-Flush-Fitting-Trilogy-1-ckusp536f6247065vd8s3vc4z5.pngSix-Prong-Flush-Fitting-Trilogy-2-ckusp83qc40982265tuj05r12t7.pngSix-Prong-Flush-Fitting-Trilogy-3-ckusp52q46245265vds1u9wpbh.pngSix-Prong-Flush-Fitting-Trilogy-4-ckusp533o40912865tuouo2tjpi.png
 
One more, this made by Fana
I like the clean lines of this but I am looking for a much lower set center (and no extra surprise stones)

7ab77682-a988-46a1-86b2-0310b63ad2f6.jpg.800x800_q85_background.jpg
408e9ef0-3e7c-492a-a342-6a10e7b1315c.jpg.800x800_q85_background.jpg0d25d831-3b02-4295-b121-294baf4f02ab.jpg.800x800_q85_background.jpg5fe8aa72-d5ed-44a5-ba39-a79d0dcc3277.jpg.800x800_q85_background.jpg
 
I like the Canera one.

Not what you are looking for, but in case you want an alternative, and/or someone interested in the thread title is looking for inspo, here is a round diamond set in a square setting with flat baguettes. It is very comfortable.

IMG_9290.jpeg
 
Before this one sold there was a profile shot. It is set low. And I don’t think it was cathedral.
It is from Old World Diamonds.
IMG_1343.jpeg
 
Last edited:
I like the Canera one.

Not what you are looking for, but in case you want an alternative, and/or someone interested in the thread title is looking for inspo, here is a round diamond set in a square setting with flat baguettes. It is very comfortable.

IMG_9290.jpeg
Thank you for this, @oncrutchesrightnow !
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top