Newbie need HELP in selecting Cushion Cut Diamond

[bryceman]

Hi Everyone,

I''ve been in the market for a cushion cut diamond around 1.2 carats and have located 4 diamonds of interest.

1.20ct G VS1 GIA 6.48x5.85x4.03 Pol:VG Sym:GD Flour:None $7,400 : GIA Report #1
1.20ct F VS1 GIA 6.40x5.96x4.12 Pol:EX Sym:VG Flour:None $8,000 : GIA Report #2
1.20ct E VS1 GIA 6.36x5.81x4.09 Pol:VG Sym:VG Flour:None $8,300 : GIA Report #3
1.21ct D VVS2 GIA 6.87x6.43x3.99 Pol:VG Sym:G Flour:None $7,622 : GIA Report #4

I have attached all 4 GIA reports. Had to do it in 4 seperate posts to upload. Can anyone give me any advice of which diamond would be best? The diamond will be placed in a style similar to Tiffany''s Simple Legacy.

Thank you for your help!!!! It''s a lot of money to spend without consulting the experts on Pricescope!

 

[bryceman]

Here''s the second GIA Report

 

[bryceman]

Here''s the 3rd

 

[bryceman]

And finally the 4th. Thanks for any advice!!!

 

[neatfreak]

None of the reports are showing up sadly. Do you have more information like pictures or ASET images? Cushions really need to be seen and bought with your eyes...unfortunately there are no formulas like there are with RB''s.

 

[bryceman]

Here''s a picture of the last diamond that I posted. Seems to be my favorite. What does everyone think?

 

[Lorelei]

It looks great, could you reload the other pics please so we can get a good comparison? Who has the diamond you like, which vendor?

 

[stone_seeker]

Date: 9/30/2008 12:32:42 AM
Author: bryceman
Here''s a picture of the last diamond that I posted. Seems to be my favorite. What does everyone think?

Great looking stone! I cant see pictures of the others either. Do you have depth and table specs? Numbers dont mean much for cushions so as any pictures as possible (and ASET if available) would be useful.

 

[CharmyPoo]

I will throw another one in the mix. I have seen this one in person and it is beautiful. Although it has a larger table than I typically like, I found it to be very pretty.

1.20ct F VVS2 GIA 6.30x6.10x4.17 Pol:VG Sym:G Flour:None $8,076 : GIA Report 17183245

http://www.engagementringsdirect.com/loose_detail.php/session/a174872a42c965c3e3b5d3292d4c88d8/id/17398020/sz/150/premium/premium

 

[CharmyPoo]

Are you looking for a squarish or rectangular shape? What L:W ratio do you want?

I believe the Tiffany Legacy is pretty square.