Need some help with Depth, Girdle, and cut questions.

[jmicro]

Im buying a diamond and have been given four options. Im doing this over the internet with a trusted dealer, I just want to choose the best diamond, but don't really know enough about the subject to form a intelligent choice. Could some of you chime in on what you would pick and which ones to stay away from. I have four choices for a ring.
Thanks
1

Shape Weight Depth % Table % Girdle Polish Symmetry Clarity
EMERALD 1.5 70.4 65 THICK GOOD GOOD VVS 2
PRINCESS 1.5 68.3 75 VERY THICK VERY GOOD VERY GOOD VS 1
ROUND 1.5 62.7 55.5 SLIGHTLY THICK, FACETED EXCELLENT VERY GOOD VVS 2
RADIANT 1.5 71.0 72.5 SLIGHTLY THICK EXCELLENT VERY GOOD VS 1[/size]

 

[Dancing Fire]

gezz,your all over the map... 4 different shapes?

 

[diamondseeker2006]

Okay, I will also ask why are looking at 4 different shapes? Doesn't she have a preference? If she doesn't, then I would suggest a round.

With that said, I will help you with the round as we'd have to have photos of the others to give an opinion. That round is too deep. But what we'd need to know about any rounds is this:

table
depth
crown angle
pavilion angle
girdle

diameter measurements

color
clarity
weight

Does it have a GIA report?

If this is the only round you have to choose from, I would consider looking at other internet dealers. We can help you find stones if you do.