Need opinion- which one?

[met]

Ok-

I think I finally got it narrowed down to two diamonds. I have not seen it, but these are the specs on it. Which one should I go with- the price is neck to neck.....should be a win-win situation according to the guy.

1. GIA- G-class,VS1, 2.10carat, 3 excellents - table and depth % falls within perfect range. (8.2mm x)


2. GIA- F-class, VS1, 2.03carat, 3 excellents- table & depth good too --however, this has strong flourescence (8.1mmx)

Thanks for your time.

 

[jet2ks]

Not enough information.

If these are rounds then we would need diameter, table, depth, crown & pavillion angles at the very least. Pictures and performance images, such as Idealscope, would be very helpful, as well, but from the information you have given, there is nothing we can really help with.

 

[met]

here''s some more info:

1. GIA- G-class, 2.10, VS1- table= 57%, depth= 61.1.%, cutlet= none, 3-excellent on the cut, no flourescene
- measurement (8.25 x 8.2



2. GIA- F-class, 2.03, VS1- tablet= 55%, depth= 62.5%, cutlet= none, 3-excellent on the cut, strong flourescene
- measurement (8.07 x 8.12)


Again, I haven''t seen these yet. But I just want to know which one has the best numbers?

 

[met]

oh- forgot, this is a round- cut

 

[stone-cold11]

Please post the crown and pavilion angles. Also the star and lower facet numbers.

 

[Ellen]

Still need crown and pavilion angles, they''re important.

 

[Lorelei]

Date: 8/17/2009 6:06:26 PM
Author: Ellen
Still need crown and pavilion angles, they''re important.

Absolutely, these measurements are crucial.