Need help with making a choice

[Trojanus]

I have brought myself down to two diamond choices and would like some input.

The first choice is waiting to be checked for being eyeclean: 0.61 Hearts and Arrows

The second is a nice one that I found on my own, though it is a bit smaller carat:
0.57 Hearts and Arrows

I am looking at possibly pairing it with a Divisi or a Cathedral if I can find it in White Gold. If you have any advice for similar settings, let me know.

Thanks-

Mike

 

[Sparkalicious]

#1 - Looks great and scores 1.8 Excellent on the Holloway Cut Advisor!

My only concern with this stone is the inclusions. There appear to be some black inclusions in this diamond, therefore, I would recommend asking the vendor to pull them and see if they would consider them eye-clean - or to verify whether or not the inclusions can be seen with the naked eye.

#2 - I really like this one. The color is fantastic and this diamond looks as though there are very few inclusions and no black ones that are easy to see. This diamond also rates 1.3 Excellent on the HCA

Both of these diamonds appear to be winners, cut wise, however, my personal feeling is that #2 has the slight edge due to the fact it is an F color and that it appears, based on the pics provided to have less obvious inclusions.

If you like either of them ... Hold them. It appears as thought these things are flying off the shelves nowadays.

Good luck and let us know what you decide!

 

[chrono]

You have picked excellent diamonds, either one would be lovely. The Divisi is a lovely setting too.

 

[Trojanus]

I am leading towards #2, but again, waiting on feedback regarding those inclusions and whether or not it is eyeclean from the people at WF.

 

[Sparkalicious]

Date: 12/11/2007 8:01:06 PM
Author: Trojanus

I am leading towards #2, but again, waiting on feedback regarding those inclusions and whether or not it is eyeclean from the people at WF.

Good stuff!

I hope it comes up clean! Pls let us know!