Hello all,
I need some feedback selecting between two princess cut diamonds. We found two diamonds in our price range and I cannot decide which one is the better deal/value for our money. We were told that both diamonds ideal cuts. The price difference is $1060 between the G/SI2 and H/SI1. There isn't much of a size difference between the two diamonds - the H SI1 is slightly smaller in size but more square.
2.03 H SI1
Polish/Symmetry = Excellent/Excellent
Table - 71%
Depth - 71.1%
2.15 G SI2
Polish/Symmetry = Excellent/Very good
Table - 70%
Depth - 71.8%
The jeweler who has the 2.03 got a hold of the 2.15 and said that while it is a great stone, she doesn't think it is as brilliant as it should be although the bf and I compared them side by side and could not see much of a difference. Any thoughts on which may be a better deal/value. Should I choose color and bigger carat weight over clarity even if the actual size of the stones aren't too far apart?
I need some feedback selecting between two princess cut diamonds. We found two diamonds in our price range and I cannot decide which one is the better deal/value for our money. We were told that both diamonds ideal cuts. The price difference is $1060 between the G/SI2 and H/SI1. There isn't much of a size difference between the two diamonds - the H SI1 is slightly smaller in size but more square.
2.03 H SI1
Polish/Symmetry = Excellent/Excellent
Table - 71%
Depth - 71.1%
2.15 G SI2
Polish/Symmetry = Excellent/Very good
Table - 70%
Depth - 71.8%
The jeweler who has the 2.03 got a hold of the 2.15 and said that while it is a great stone, she doesn't think it is as brilliant as it should be although the bf and I compared them side by side and could not see much of a difference. Any thoughts on which may be a better deal/value. Should I choose color and bigger carat weight over clarity even if the actual size of the stones aren't too far apart?