Need Help!!! Picking between two Princess Cut diamonds

[ervinboy2012]

I really need someone opinion about these two diamonds. I am in the Air Force and I am coming home from a TDY to propose to my girl. Ok here are the two princess cut diamonds

1) VVS2 clarity, I color, 1.25 carat---$4500
2)SI2 clarity, D color, 1.31 carat----$5000

I dont know whether to sacrifice color for clarity or vice versa. I am not a diamond expert or no where near it. So any advice well help than none....THANKS!!!

 

[CharmedOne]

Do you have photos or specs? You might want to post this in rocky talk, you will probably get more help there with photos and specs. They can also suggest more options for you there

 

[ervinboy2012]

No I dont have any specs or pics, but I will take your advice and put it on the other forum

 

[Craig]

SI2 clarity, D color, 1.31 carat----$5000 --go for this D color is the best color you get

VVS2 clarity, I color, 1.25 carat is a very bad combination since I color will not compliment the calarity VVS2

Go for color, Look matters right