Need help picking a diamond.

[graysky111]

Hello. I searched some diamonds below 1 carat and now trying to pick from these three.

Number 1: .9 Carat, Excellent Cut, I color, SI1, Depth and Table % 59.9 & 60, GIA 2136295032
Nubmer 2: .9 Carat, Very Good Cut, G color, SI1, Depth and Table % 58.7 & 60, GIA 2131980048
Number 3: .9 Carat, Very Good Cut, I color, VS2, Depth and Table % 59.2 & 61, GIA 2136249894

Polish, Symmetry all Excellent, and M-STK girdle, No Culet, No Fluorescence.

Below is the feedback for first one I received from the website.
Small crystal, white inclusion in the corner of the table which is not easily visible with naked eyes & it also includes hair line open.
Very small black inclusion in the corner of the table.
Diamond is OK.

I wish if I can actually see the diamond but I am trying to buy online, so I can't do it.
Unless I order like 2 diamond and return and then order with settings which really could take some time.
All are in pretty similar price range - no wonder - like less than $100 differences.

If you could help me to pick one of these three, I would really appreciate it.
I am getting too much headache from picking a diamond.
Thank you very much.

 

[diamondseeker2006]

Well, I am going to encourage you to start over and not even look at stones that are not GIA excellent cut. GIA ex is a very broad range and there are even stones within that category that may not be recommended. And I wouldn't consider the first diamond based on the comments on it. You need magnified photos of the stones and idealscope images. Does this seller offer those?

 

[diamondseeker2006]

(#2 has a table of 63%! You want to find 54-58%)