shape
carat
color
clarity

Need help picking a diamond - AGS ideal vs GIA excellent

JiJi

Rough_Rock
Joined
Jan 11, 2015
Messages
13
Hi all.

I am new to this forum, so this question may be asked a few times before but please bear with me and give me your thought on this. I am looking to buy a 1 ctw stud earrings. This will be a kind of investment for me too but I have no plan of selling them any time soon. I've narrowed down what I want to two choices.

First pair is AGS certified diamond with ideal cut (A Cut Above - Hearts and Arrows) I/VS2
DIAMOND SPECIFICATIONS
Depth % 61.4 , 61.8
Table % 55.5 , 55.9
Crown Angle 34.4 , 34.2
Star 55.0 , 50.0
Pavilion Angle 40.7 , 40.9
Crown % 15.3 , 15.0
Lower Girdle % 76.0 , 78.0
Measurements 5.17x5.20x3.19 , 5.16x5.20x3.2
Culet Pointed , Pointed
Fluorescence Negligible , Negligible
Girdle Thin to Medium Faceted , Thin to Medium Faceted

The second pair is GIA certified G/VS1 with excellent cut.

Measurements: 5.08 x 5.10 x 3.20mm , 5.13 x 5.15 x 3.21mm
Depth %: 62.9% , 62.4%
Table %: 55% , 56%
Crown Angle 35.5 , 35.5
Pavilion Angle 41.0 , 40.8
Symmetry: Excellent , Excellent
Polish: Excellent , Excellent
Fluorescence: None
Clarity characteristic - Cloud, Feather, Needle, Pinpoint in one diamond --- should I be concerned?

Both pairs cost pretty much the same. So my question is which pair should I pick? I want it to look better on my ears and if I ever have to sell at higher price too ><

I've read that with ideal cut (A Cut Above) can make the diamonds look more sparkly/brilliant and whiter than regular excellent cut but is it better to the degree that surpass the next grade?

Which pair would you pick and why? Any thought on this would be greatly appreciate :)
 
If the cost is the same I'd go for ACA's.
 
@ecf8503 - Thanks! Any particular reason?
 
Angles on the GIA stones aren't as good as the ACAs. I'd go for those too. Plus they have a better upgrade policy.
 
@ecf8503 - Thanks! I thought about the better upgrade policy too and actually I am leaning toward the ACA too!

Another question that has always in the back of my mind is - Is it worth it to spend $800 more to upgrade from I/VS2 to G/VS1 both are ACA. Can you tell a difference between these two with naked eyes keeping in mind they are only 0.5 ct each? My budget is flexible but I also want to be more economical about it. Thanks!
 
Not in these smaller sizes for earrings.
 
ACA's
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top