shape
carat
color
clarity

Need Help Choosing a Diamond

Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.

OPA Rocks

Rough_Rock
Joined
Oct 2, 2007
Messages
12
Hi Everyone. Some of you may recognize me from some of my previous posts. My diamond search is hopefully coming to an exciting conclusion as I narrow in on a few options. I have been looking for a 1.25ct near color-less "eye clean" diamond with a very good to excellent cut. My budget is somewhere between $5000 and $6000 for the center stone.

I told myself in the beginning of the diamond search that I did not want to go lower than an H in color, but many jewelers and other experts I have talked to say that an I color is ok too. I have seen H''s and I''s in person, and sometimes I see no difference, but other times (when the jeweler sets them in a white trough on their sides) I do see a yellowish color. I also told myself to stick to an eye clean SI1 for the value, however I do have one VS2 here just because it has such a nice HCA score. At this point I think these are all nice stone. Let me know what you think is the best bang for my buck, as well as your opinion on the H vs. I color issue. Thank you!

Carat Color Clarity GIRD Pol Sym Cut Depth Table CrwnAng PavAng HCA Cost
1.20 I SI1 TN-STK vg vg ex 60.9 57 34 41 1.4 $4,996 6.83x6.89x4.18
1.25 I SI1 TN-M vg vg vg 59.7 57 33.5 40.8 0.8 $5,530 7.01x7.03x4.19
1.23 I VS2 VTN-TN ex ex vg 61.3 55 34.9 40.7 1.1 $5,917 6.92x6.95x4.25
1.22 H SI1 M-STK vg vg ex 61.4 57 34 41 1.4 $5,937 6.85x6.90x4.22
 
obviously, they are all pretty close by the numbers. really, if you want to narrow it down more, you would need to get an idealscope image.
i''d be inclined to go for the ''h'' but you can certainly save some $$ going with the ''i''. that is a very personal decision though.
 
I only have the Idealscope and ASET for the 1.23ct I VS2. Check it out and let me know what you think. If I choose one of the other stones I can get the Idealscopes, but if you have an opinion before that let me know please.

Thanks everyone!

IS 1.23ISI1.jpg
 
Here is the ASET.

ASET 1.23 ISI1.jpg
 
I would normally avoid a girdle of very thin, and that would eliminate the I VS2 stone. I''d probably go with the H stone.
 
Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top