shape
carat
color
clarity

Need feedback on these stones for studs.

Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.

miraclesrule

Ideal_Rock
Joined
Mar 29, 2008
Messages
4,442
Okay, this is going to be a little long. I am looking at two pair of earrings. One for me and one for my daughter. I already got the blessing for the pendant stone. I don''t have any qualms on those stone. I just received the information on the 4 stones for the two pair of studs.

Please bear with me as it is a lot of information that I am searching through. Because these will be on my ears, I am not being as picky as to the color and clarity, but expect great cut. Although I am leaning toward a preference for OEC''s and OMC''s, these are RB ideals triple ex from Canada with GIA certs. I am particularly concerned about the inclusions in the smaller pair with twining, feather and cloud. I don''t know if that should be cause for a better pricing. They are my ears so it''s not like I am likely to notice, but in the event they are set in a ring in the future, I want to make sure the SI2 is not an issue.

The first stone for the studs:

GIA2101787848
0.71 J S12 Ex H&A
Clarity: Feather
Polish and Symmetry: EX
Flor: None

mr2101787848 ASETearring1 dd.jpg
 
Idealscope stone 1

mr2101787848 Idealscopeearring1DD.jpg
 
GIA 2101788391
0.72 J SI2 Ex H&A
Clarity: feather
Polish and Symmetry: EX
Flor-None

ASET Stone 2

mr2101788391 ASETearring2 DD.jpg
 
Idealscope Stone 2

mr2101788391 Idealscope earring2 DD.jpg
 
Side by Side Zoom

mr side by side earrings DD.jpg
 
My notes are little scrambled because I have been comparing so many, but it looks like the price quote was $3300 with the settings included.

What are your thoughts? I will post another thread on the smaller studs that I am looking for my own ears. These are for my daughters. I hope they aren''t too big. GAH...how can we say that? This size just doesn''t work for me, so I am going smaller. That is another thread. I couldn''t locate the stat info on the scanned certs that ID Jewelry send me.
I guess I need to look them up. They are Canadian stones.

Let the opinions begin!! I really value your input.
 
J, as these are said to be h&a can you get hearts images for each if this is important to you?
 
Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top