Need advice

[togeppii]

Im in dilema between 2 diamonds atm.. I have two diamond offered to me, both same size 0.76 carat and both Ideal Heart and Arrow.
I know cut wise they both are really good the only differences are:

First Diamond : F color SI1
Second Diamond: G color VVS1

Can i tell the difference? Its an extra 500 for the VVS1 so it tempted me but the other one has better color (in the near colorless range)

Thanks for any input i can get

 

[stone-cold11]

Please give other information that you have on the stones. Dimensions, table and depth %, crown, pavilion angles, girdles thickness, star and lower girdle facet size.

With the present info, I would go with F SI1 assuming eye-clean.

 

[Lorelei]

Besides the info needed that SC listed, do you have images to prove these are h&a diamonds such as hearts images and some for arrows please? Do you know if the SI1 is eyeclean?

Which grading lab please, GIA, AGS or other?

 

[togeppii]

First Diamond:

Catalog No. 1470073
Shape Round
Carat 0.76
Colour F
Clarity SI1
Depth 61.90
Table 56.00
Cut ICE Ideal H&A
Report AGS
Dimensions 5.85*5.83*3.61
Pavilion Depth
Crown Angle 34.60
Pavilion Angle 40.70
Girdle 1.9-4.2F
Culet PT
Fluorescence N
Lustre
Polish ID
Symmetry ID


Second Diamond:

Catalog No. 1560586
Shape Round
Carat 0.76
Colour G
Clarity VVS1
Depth 61.70
Table 55.00
Cut ICE Ideal H&A
Report GIA
Dimensions 5.88*5.82*3.61
Girdle M-STK
Culet N
Fluorescence Faint
Lustre
Polish EX
Symmetry EX
Pavillion Depth/Crown Angle not known yet.. Ill have to ask the lady again on monday but its graded by GIA as heart and arrow.

Thanks

 

[stone-cold11]

GIA do not grade H&A. It probably just state what is engraved on the girdle. As Lorelei said before, the only way to confirm if it is an actual H&A is to look at the image of the stone through a H&A scope, we will need both the hearts image, pavilion face up, and arrow image, table face up position.