Need advice on a 1.74 stone

[teri h]

Hi... I am re-posting a question, my first post was confusing

My question is which stone is better.
First stone:
GIA Cert. 1.65 carat
Round Brilliant
Meas: 7.58 - 7.65 - 4.71
Depth: 61.9 %
Table: 55 %
Girdle: thin to slightly thick faceted
Culet: None
Polish: Good
Symmetry: Good
Clarity/color: E SI2
no flour
Second stone:

EGL US 32122415D
Round Brilliant 1.74 carat
Meas: 7.74 - 7.67 x 4.78
Depth: 62.1 %
Table: 56 %
Crown: 15.5
Pavilion: 43.0
Girdle: Thin to medium faceted
Polish: Good
Symmetry: Good
no flour

Any comments are greatly appreciated...

 

[Garry H (Cut Nut)]

Symmetry is a question here.

It would be easiest all round if you can get ideal-scope images for both.
EGL good may not be as good as GIA good

Also is it EGL USA (better)

 

[valeria101]

What is the color and clarity of the EGL graded diamond ?

If it matches GIA word for word, the meaning of the grades might not be the same. Also, if both are SI clarity, the looks of the inclusions would affect value quite a bit - it does matter how clean they look and that''s not possible to tell without the diamonds infront of you (or some darn good pictures).

Just my 0.2

 

[JohnQuixote]

A Sarin report (angle info) would be helpful.

 

[teri h]

thanks for responding, the EGL is US, and the color and clarity is F SI2. I also paid $11,300 for the GIA stone

and the EGL stone is $10,877. I bought my stone at a store called the "Jewelry Exchange" in Tustin, CA

they have several stores nationwide, I wish I had purchased my stone with Whiteflash or dirt cheap diamonds

I could have saved myself some money, the Jewelry Exchange gives a 90 day full value trade up and after that

you get 80 % of what you paid towards upgrading, which isn''t too bad. Thanks again for answering my

question

teri