Need a set of experienced eyes to help me decide

[cheradrian]

I have been lurking on PS for a couple days/weeks now and I was wondering if one (or more) of you more experienced folks could take a look at the images attached (if it works) and let me know what your thoughts are and help me choose between the two.

Thanks in advance.

DETAILS:
- both are ~1ctw
- both are G colored (even if the image on the left looks slightly more yellow)
- one is SI1 clarity and the other is SI2 (can you tell which is which?)
- one scored HCA 1.2 and the other scored HCA 1.5

 

[cheradrian]

 

[cheradrian]

 

[cheradrian]

 

[T L]

The one on the right has a larger table, so you will probably get more fire and dispersion out of it. It also appears to be more symmetrical in it's facet pattern. It might also face up larger. Do you have the mm sizes on both stones?

 

[Daisi2112]

I think it would help us more if you had angles, etc...

 

[Stephan]

Left one is HCA 1.5, SI2.
Right?

 

[jet2ks]

I flipped a coin ten times and it came up for the one on the left five times and the one on the right five times.

Seriously, they are that close and both are very well cut stones.

tl--I was under the impression that in general the smaller tables tended to show more fire and larger more brilliance--dependent on angles of course. Am I missing something?

 

[Stephan]

I love the one on the right.
Brian has nice diamonds!

 

[Lorelei]

Both beauties, the one on the right appeals to me most.

 

[cheradrian]

Sorry for the late response... but I just want to say thanks for helping out a "rough rock" to decide!

Cheers!

 

[Lorelei]

Date: 5/17/2009 10:45:23 PM
Author: cheradrian
Sorry for the late response... but I just want to say thanks for helping out a ''rough rock'' to decide!

Cheers!

Most welcome!