Narrowed it down but need help picking the best one!

[slm9555]

I narrowed my search down to the following choices. I'm going to pull the trigger in the next 24 hours or so and any advice would be greatly appreciated!!

Applicable to all: Round diamond from Blue Nile, all priced within $200-$300 of each other, all excellent polish and symmetry

(1)
G VS1
.63 ct
l/w 1.01
depth 60.4
table 57
34.5* / 40.6*
5.60 x 5.57 x 3.37
Clarity: feather, needle
Florescence None
Polish/Sym/Cut: EEE
Girdle: Thin to medium

(2)
F VVS2
.64 ct
l/w 1.01
depth 60.9
table 56
34.0* / 40.8*
5.60 x 5.56 x 3.40
Clarity: feather, needle, chip, pin point
Florescence None
Polish/Sym/Cut: EEE
Girdle: Thin to medium

(3)
G VS1
.61 ct
l/w 1.01
depth 61.5
table 57
35.0* / 40.6*
5.47 x 5.44 x 3.36
Clarity: Cloud
Florescence None
Polish/Sym/Cut: EEE
Girdle: Medium

(4)
G VVS2
.60 ct
l/w 1.01
depth 61.3
table 57
34.5* / 40.6*
5.44 x 5.39 x 3.32
Clarity: Pinpoint, Internal Graining, Cloud, Surface Graining
Florescence Faint
Polish/Sym/Cut: EEE
Girdle: Medium

(5)
F VS1
.60 ct
l/w 1.01
depth 61.5
table 56
34.5* / 40.8*
5.41 x 5.44 x 3.34
Clarity: Feather, Pinpoint
Florescence None
Polish/Sym/Cut: EEE
Girdle: Medium to ST

(6)
G VS1
.64 ct
l/w 1.0
depth 61.7
table 56
34.5* / 40.8*
5.52 x 5.54 x 3.41
Clarity: Cloud, Pinpoint
Florescence None
Polish/Sym/Cut: EEE
Girdle: Medium to ST

 

[Gypsy]

3

 

[slm9555]

3

Thank you Gypsy. Any reason for #3 over #1? I have been leaning towards number #1. However, I have only been researching this for a couple days so I am very new to this and what to look for.

 

[Gypsy]

The first one is bigger in terms of spread and also has good numbers. Go for it. I didn't look at spread. Just at clarity and the numbers. I'm a fan of 35/40.6 combos.

 

[slm9555]

Do you think the difference in size between 1 and 3 will be noticeable to the naked eye? Will the difference in depth ratio between the two make any difference in performance? Thanks a ton for your input it's much appreciated.

 

[Shondra]

Not an expert, but I think that the difference in size wouldn't be much noticeable to the naked eye. Looking at your options above, I think you should go with #1